---
title: value capture for the ground that protects you
canonical_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/value-capture-for-the-ground-that-protects-you
markdown_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/value-capture-for-the-ground-that-protects-you.md
subtitle: flood protection raises land and property values. cities capture part of that with a charge. the people who gain could invest part of it in the ground upstream instead
category: nature-finance
---

# value capture for the ground that protects you

*flood protection raises land and property values. cities capture part of that with a charge. the people who gain could invest part of it in the ground upstream instead*

**Value capture** is how a public body recovers part of the rise in land values its own work creates. It does it with a charge: assessments on parcels that benefit, charges on new development, or a share of the uplift on land it sells or leases. Flood protection is a classic case: lower risk raises prices, and the city charges for part of it.

That is the public sector's tool, and it already works in a handful of places. It also has a blind spot. When the protection comes from a floodplain field, a wetland or a wooded slope upstream, the price rises on Main Street and the ground that did the work often gets nothing. The people whose value rises could invest part of that gain in the ground upstream instead, by choice.

## why value capture matters for adaptation

Adaptation pays. The McKinsey Global Institute's November 2026 report, *Advancing adaptation*, puts the societal benefit of its 20 measures at about three times the cost today, rising to about seven at 2°C of warming by 2050 (a planning scenario, not a forecast). Those measures are mostly engineered; nature-based ones are a small share. Much of it still isn't built. MGI's reading is that in higher-income places the main obstacles are misaligned incentives (the people who gain aren't the ones who fund the work) and revenue risk: a levee or a detention basin produces avoided loss, not a cash flow a lender can count.

So MGI lists ways to turn a resilience benefit into predictable revenue: user fees, beneficiary payments, value capture, payments tied to future savings, and asset bundling. Strictly, value capture is one of the five; in practice the first three find where the benefit lands and charge there, while the fourth redirects a saving. This post uses that wider sense and four of MGI's examples, each checked at its source. Value capture also has preconditions: a land registry, a tax base and the political will to add a charge. Every example here is in a high-income place.

## four places that already capture the value of protection

**Sacramento: assessments priced to each parcel's benefit.** The Sacramento Area Flood Control Agency (SAFCA) funds levee work partly through benefit assessment districts. The largest, Consolidated Capital Assessment District No. 2, formed in 2016, covers the area's major floodplains and is split into eight zones by source of flooding, such as the American River, the Sacramento River or Morrison Creek. SAFCA's rule is plain: owners are assessed only for projects that benefit their property. Each parcel's share reflects how deep the water could get if a levee failed, plus its acreage and building area. The charge arrives on the county property-tax bill. This is MGI's example of a beneficiary payment.

**Boston: development rights in return for flood protection.** The Raymond L. Flynn Marine Industrial Park is 190 acres of city-owned land on the South Boston waterfront, and the city's preliminary estimate for protecting it ran to more than $200 million. Under the Climate Resiliency Infrastructure Contribution Program, developers who get the right to build offices, laboratories and hotels on city-owned parcels there contribute part of that cost. A 2024 Lincoln Institute working paper describes how the program was designed and says its outcomes are hard to measure yet, because it is so new. Treat it as a design, not a result.

**Copenhagen: the water tariff funds the cloudburst works.** After the July 2011 cloudburst flooded the city, Copenhagen drew up a cloudburst management plan and lobbied for a national rule change. Under that change, the utility HOFOR can fund cloudburst works, including some multifunctional surface solutions, from water tariffs, as long as the spending is tied to handling wastewater. The city's own budget covers the urban-space improvements around them. MGI counts this as a user fee.

**MyStrongHome: the roof repaid from the premium it lowers.** MyStrongHome has financed roofs in Alabama, Louisiana and South Carolina built to the FORTIFIED standard, which can earn the homeowner a lower windstorm premium. The homeowner kept paying about what they paid before. MyStrongHome passed the new, lower premium to the insurer and kept the difference to pay off the roof; once it was paid, the saving was the homeowner's. MGI's term is a payment tied to future savings. It is the one of the four that raises nobody's costs. For how premium savings can flow back to land, see [share the premium saving with the land](/guide/share-the-premium-saving-with-the-land?from=guide) and [does mitigation lower insurance premiums](/guide/does-mitigation-lower-insurance-premiums?from=guide). This post won't retell them.

| place | who funds it | what the charge tracks | what it funds |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sacramento | Owners in each benefit zone | Each parcel's flood benefit | Levees and flood works |
| Boston | Developers on city land | Building rights | Waterfront flood protection |
| Copenhagen | Water customers | Water use | Cloudburst pipes, tunnels and some surface works |
| MyStrongHome | The homeowner's own premium saving, no new cost | The premium saving | The roof |

Four tools, four units. Three of the four find who gains from protection and add a charge; the fourth redirects a saving. That is the public sector's way; it isn't ours.

## the step value capture leaves out

Look at what each tool funds: a levee, a waterfront defence, pipes and tunnels, a roof. Most of it sits on public land, inside a utility, or on the protected parcel, so it is easy to name and fund.

Natural flood protection doesn't sit there. The field that floods on purpose upstream, the wetland that holds a storm's first hours, the wooded slope that slows run-off: each one lowers the water downstream, and none of them is on the parcel whose value rises. Real estate has measured this spillover for decades. Homes near parks and under canopy sell for more, and the trees off your lot move your price more than the ones on it ([do parks increase property values](/guide/do-parks-increase-property-values?from=guide)). For flood protection the same logic plausibly holds at the scale of a catchment. Measuring it is harder.

Follow the chain:

1. **The living asset does work.** A floodplain field stores water; a wetland slows the peak.
2. **The work changes a risk.** Water is lower, or arrives later, on the parcels below.
3. **The risk reaches a price.** Lower expected loss can show up in a premium, a sale price, a lending decision and, over time, the tax roll.
4. **The price is captured where it lands.** Sometimes by an assessment, a fee or a premium saving. More often by no one at all.
5. **Nothing goes back up the chain.** No money reaches the field, and its owner is often offered more to drain it, build on it or farm it harder.

Economists call the first half a [spillover effect](/guide/what-is-a-spillover-effect-in-nature?from=guide). The second half is the gap: property markets price the uplift downstream but have no standard way to see the upstream source, let alone invest in it. Value capture, as practised, mostly closes that gap for gray works. For living ones it mostly hasn't, with a few exceptions such as stormwater credits and some surface works.

:::johnson
**the value shows up in someone's price; part of it can be invested back in the ground that made it.** — Value capture already knows how to find the people who gain. The missing step is an address for the source that they can choose to invest in.

[read how a protective wall can move the risk instead →](/guide/maladaptation-moves-the-harm-downstream?from=guide)
:::

## what changes when the ground has an account

The hard part of funding an upstream field has never been the money. The people who gain already spend on flood risk: in premiums, in damage and repairs, in grants and donations after the water goes down. None of that spending is an investment in the thing that protects them. The hard part is that the field has no address: nothing a homeowner, a developer, a utility or a treasurer can invest in and audit.

**Ensurance** is designed to give it one. A natural asset (a floodplain reach, a wetland, a wooded catchment) can be represented by an agent with its own account on a public ledger. The place is the subject; the agent is its address. People and organisations who depend on that place can choose to invest in it through that account, each by the accounting unit they already use and on their own budget cycle. That could be part of the uplift in a property's value, part of what they would otherwise lose to the next flood, or part of a premium saving. Money reaching the account funds the natural asset first, then the people who keep it, such as the farmer whose field floods on purpose or the land trust that manages the wetland. Every flow is visible and addressed to the place it serves. A conventional fund could hold the money too; a public ledger lets everyone who invests, of any size, audit the same account without asking for a report.

Value capture adds a charge to the people who gain; ensurance offers them a voluntary way in. The design asks for no new cost: the money is what they already spend on flood risk, redirected, and ensurance sends no bill.

Two limits. A certificate records support for a named place. It is not a claim on the land, and title stays where it is. It promises no financial return. The landowner's consent comes first, and they can say no. And an account doesn't measure anything by itself. Attribution, meaning how much of the lower water came from this field and not from the levee or the weather, is modelled, not proven, and the evidence behind any investment has to be stated and checked.

## the objections, honestly

**"Isn't this just another tax?"** No. The design levies nothing and sends no bill; every investment is a choice. Cities that charge can still look upstream: the [stormwater utility fee](/guide/what-a-stormwater-utility-fee-is-paying-for?from=guide) already shows one city letting another parcel's rain garden count.

**"Won't two investors claim the same benefit?"** They might if each one counts the whole benefit alone. The shares have to add up to no more than the whole benefit, which takes an attribution model that splits it among the people who depend on the place. Sacramento's zone-by-zone method is the closest existing model for the split, though it is used there to set a charge.

**"Can a private owner do this without a city?"** Yes, in principle. An owner can invest in the living system on another parcel that lowers its own flood losses, with money it would otherwise lose to damage or spend on repairs. [How a property owner funds nature-based solutions on another parcel](/guide/how-a-property-owner-pays-for-nature-based-solutions-on-another-parcel?from=guide) walks through that path.

**"Has ensurance done this for a floodplain?"** Not yet. No contract of this kind is in place on ensurance today. The closest real precedent, five parties who gain from natural flood management in Lancashire's Wyre catchment contracting outcome payments for it, was someone else's work; [natural flood management: the field is the infrastructure](/guide/natural-flood-management-the-field-is-the-infrastructure?from=guide) tells it. If you have a floodplain in mind, [get in touch](/contact?from=guide&topic=adaptation-gap) or [suggest it as a place](/specific/create?mode=suggest&from=guide).

## frequently asked questions

### what is value capture?

Value capture is a set of tools a public body uses to recover part of the rise in land and property values that its own investment creates. It works by adding a charge. Common forms are special or benefit assessments, development charges and a share of the uplift on public land it sells or leases.

### how is value capture used for flood protection?

Cities charge the parcels whose flood risk falls. Sacramento assesses owners by benefit zone and possible flood depth. Boston asks developers on city-owned waterfront land to contribute to flood infrastructure. Copenhagen funds cloudburst works through water tariffs.

### why doesn't value capture fund natural flood protection?

Because the value usually comes from another parcel. A floodplain or wetland upstream lowers flood risk downstream, but it sits outside the benefit zone and has no address anyone can invest in, so the uplift is captured downstream or not at all.

### is there a way to do this without a new charge?

Yes. The people whose value rises can choose to invest part of that gain, of what they would otherwise lose, or of a premium saving in the ground upstream. That is the route ensurance offers.

## next steps

If you run a flood program, a resilience program or a stormwater utility, ask one question of your next flood project: which ground upstream is already doing part of this work, and could the people who gain from it be given a way to invest in it, without a new charge? Then see how a place gets an account on [natural assets](/natural-assets?from=guide), and what [ensurance offers governments](/solutions/governments?from=guide&topic=adaptation-gap).

Next in the series: [maladaptation moves the harm downstream](/guide/maladaptation-moves-the-harm-downstream?from=guide). To talk through a catchment, [get in touch](/contact?from=guide&topic=adaptation-gap).

Nothing here is investment, legal or tax advice.

## sources

[McKinsey Global Institute — Advancing adaptation: Breaking barriers to a trillion-dollar opportunity, November 2026](https://www.mckinsey.com/mgi/our-research/Advancing-adaptation-Breaking-barriers-to-a-trillion-dollar-opportunity) — benefit-to-cost of about 3× today and 7× at 2°C; demand and financing barriers; five ways to create revenue and the four examples used here

[Sacramento Area Flood Control Agency — assessment districts](https://www.safca.org/assessment-districts/) — CCAD 2 (2016), eight zones by flood source, assessment only for projects that benefit the property, flood depth, acreage and building area, billed on the county tax bill

[Lincoln Institute of Land Policy — Financing Climate Resilient Infrastructure for Boston's Waterfront (Minjee Kim, July 2024)](https://www.lincolninst.edu/publications/working-papers/financing-climate-resilient-infrastructure-boston-waterfront/) — the Climate Resiliency Infrastructure Contribution Program, the Raymond L. Flynn Marine Industrial Park, estimate above $200 million, outcomes not yet measurable

[CLIMATEFIT / University of Antwerp — Cloudburst Management Plan: co-financing with public budget, water tariffs and private financing in Copenhagen (June 2024)](https://zenodo.org/records/13836539) — national rule change, tariff funding limited to wastewater purposes, cost split

[Centre for Liveable Cities, Singapore — Cloudburst solutions in Copenhagen](https://knowledgehub.clc.gov.sg/publications-library/cloudburst-solutions-in-copenhagen/) — HOFOR utility charges for technical works, city budget for urban space

[Next City — stormproofing coastal homes with insurance savings (November 2015)](https://nextcity.org/urbanist-news/stormproofing-coastal-homes-insurance-savings-resilient-cities) — how MyStrongHome repays a retrofit from the lower premium; Alabama, Louisiana and South Carolina

## the series

- [the adaptation gap is an investor gap](/guide/the-adaptation-gap-is-a-payer-gap?from=guide)
- [eight reasons adaptation doesn't get built](/guide/eight-reasons-adaptation-does-not-get-built?from=guide)
- [natural flood management: the field is the infrastructure](/guide/natural-flood-management-the-field-is-the-infrastructure?from=guide)
- [value capture for the ground that protects you](/guide/value-capture-for-the-ground-that-protects-you?from=guide)
- [maladaptation moves the harm downstream](/guide/maladaptation-moves-the-harm-downstream?from=guide)
- [bankable adaptation starts with the people who gain](/guide/bankable-adaptation-starts-with-a-payer?from=guide)
