---
title: two sets of books on one building
canonical_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/two-sets-of-books-on-one-building
markdown_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/two-sets-of-books-on-one-building.md
subtitle: the owner and the operator rest on the same land and each has a different stake in it
category: nature-finance
---

# two sets of books on one building

*the owner and the operator rest on the same land and each has a different stake in it*

**What is a split incentive?** In energy efficiency, a split incentive is when the one who decides on an improvement is not the one who pays the bill it would lower. The classic case is a landlord who buys the boiler while the tenant pays the gas. Neither has the full reason to fix it, so the fix waits.

The same split runs through land. Above Snowmass Village, Colorado, East Snowmass Creek drains a small wilderness valley of forest and snow, and the district that waters the town draws nearly all its daily water from it. That creek and the slopes above it were doing their work before the first lodge went up, and they do it whether or not anyone pays. A water district, a ski company and the owners of the buildings below all rest on it, each on its own books. **ensurance** is built to give a living place like that an account, so the ones who rest on it can pay for its keeping. The account is not the creek, and no account stops a fire.

:::johnson
**every set of books on the building has a stake in the creek.** Most are not invested in it yet, and the split incentive helps explain why.

[See how one source carries three ceilings →](/guide/what-a-source-is-worth-paying-for?from=guide)
:::

*This post is not insurance, legal or tax advice.*

![photo by Konstantin Dyadyun (@kostyadyadyun) on unsplash](https://images.unsplash.com/photo-1707648496492-38255a8f1877?ixid=M3w4NjQwMjZ8MHwxfGNvbGxlY3Rpb258MTk2fHZ6OFZMY25SS2pzfHx8fHwyfHwxNzk1Mjc2NjU3fA&ixlib=rb-4.1.0&w=1200&fit=crop&auto=format)

## the split incentive, from buildings to land

A 2012 paper for the American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy (ACEEE) describes split incentives "in which the entity that controls energy use does not pay the energy bill." The landlord-tenant relationship "is the most commonly cited split incentive."

The building trade has one answer on offer. The same paper says lease language that "realigns the allocation of costs, benefits, and financial risks" of efficiency between tenants and owners "offers a highly promising approach." Title stays where it is; what changes is who pays for what, and who keeps the saving.

Outdoors, the thing that lowers the bill is a forest or a creek some distance away, and more than two sets of books rest on it. Land is a looser fit: each party bears part of the loss, so the gap is who goes first, a cousin of [the free-rider problem](/guide/the-free-rider-is-standing-on-a-keystone-parcel?from=guide).

## two sets of books on one building

*One building, two sets of books, two different stakes in the same land.*

When the land above fails, the **owner** can see a write-down, a costlier renewal (or no cover at all) or a capital project; the **operator** or tenant sees closed days and higher operating cost. Behind them, the **insurer** and the **lender** each keep their own books.

| who | what moves on its books | its stake in the land |
|---|---|---|
| Owner | Asset value, premium, lender's covenants, capital projects | The value and insurability of the building |
| Operator or tenant | Days open, water and treatment, inputs | Revenue and operating cost |
| Insurer | Expected claims | What it pays out when the land fails |
| Lender | Collateral value, default risk | The loan book in that valley |

Each is a real stake, held the moment the party depends on the land, paid or not. That is the gap: *you have a stake in it. you're not invested in it.*

## a ski village on one creek

In 2019, Aspen Journalism quoted the manager of the Snowmass Water and Sanitation District: about 96 percent of the water used daily in the resort town comes from the East Snowmass Creek diversion point. In 2025 the same outlet reported that the creek's watershed is roughly 6 square miles, nestled in the Maroon Bells-Snowmass Wilderness, and that everything upstream of the intake is wilderness. The Forest Service places that wilderness in the White River and Gunnison national forests.

The distance is short: the intake sits about 20 feet downstream of the wilderness boundary. Who rests on that land:

- **The water district**, which treats and delivers the town's water.
- **The ski company**, which runs the ski area under a Forest Service special use permit on the White River National Forest.
- **The owners of the homes, lodges and shops**, and their operators.
- **Their insurers and lenders**, each with its own books.

Someone already pays. The district began expanding Ziegler Reservoir in 2011; the expansion cost $10.7 million, the district manager told Aspen Journalism. According to the manager, the ski company put $3.75 million into that project: a bill already paid, by the operator, toward the reservoir that now supplies its snowmaking. In 2017 the district filed for a backup water right on the Roaring Fork River; in 2019 its manager called it "an insurance policy for the district," a project he said would move forward only after a catastrophic event in Snowmass Creek, such as a drought, landslide or wildfire.

These are real works. Neither reaches the land the water comes from. In 2025, engineers working on a wildfire plan for the valley drafted maps showing a high likelihood of post-fire debris flows in the lower basin of East Snowmass Creek, where the headgate sits, after a hard rain of the kind that comes about every two years. One of them said that with the wilderness, "if there was a fire, there's not much you can do after."

For drinking water, the district's water resources manager said the reservoir could carry the town for three to six weeks without the streams, and called it "a short term tool, and a partial tool."

Gray works are needed. The narrower point: every party below has a stake in the land above the intake, and most are not invested in it yet. ([The resort never owned the trees](/guide/the-resort-never-owned-the-trees?from=guide) told a ski area's forest story.)

## count each loss once

When the water is off, one loss has several descriptions:

- An operator's lost revenue and the owner's lost rent on the same building overlap, so count them once.
- The insurer's claim and the owner's insured damage are one loss.
- The lender's collateral loss and the owner's lost equity are one loss.

So each party hears its own entry and keeps its share under its own ceiling. There is no total across the four; adding them would count the same dry week several times. [What a source is worth paying for](/guide/what-a-source-is-worth-paying-for?from=guide) works the arithmetic in its section "one source, three owners, three ceilings", and [split the bill for what lowers it](/guide/split-the-bill-for-what-lowers-it?from=guide) shows shares each capped by that party's own avoided loss.

## who should pay, the owner or the operator?

Here is the trap. The owner says the operator lives with the water, so the operator should pay. The operator says the owner holds the asset, so the owner should pay. If each waits, the land gets nothing and both keep the risk.

The green-lease answer still holds: change who pays for what, not who holds title. For land, both could pay toward the same place, each from its own books: the owner from the asset side, the operator from the operating side. No one should pay more than their own ceiling; below it, what anyone pays is their choice.

In wilderness the choices are narrow; the hydrologist leading the valley's report said "there is, at least for Snowmass, very little we can prescribe." What a shared payment could fund is for the Forest Service, the district and the people who know the valley to say: planning before a fire, monitoring, or work the Forest Service agrees to.

## where ensurance sits

**How the money moves.** **ensurance** has three instruments. A coin carries a theme, such as wildfire resilience. A certificate is a line or a policy. The land above this intake is wilderness in a national forest, so the fit is a **line**, a certificate for a distance, region or area no single deed covers: here, the East Snowmass Creek watershed ([how a line is named](/guide/name-the-line-for-the-buyer-not-the-town?from=guide)). A line is written when a buyer can be named who would hold the whole of it, often the kind of party that already pays for this risk (a water district); others can join it with any amount. A **policy** is a certificate for one titled parcel whose owner works with ensurance, and it carries everything that parcel provides ([how a policy works](/guide/the-natural-asset-policy-is-where-the-promise-meets-the-deed?from=guide)). A line buys policies within its mandate, parcel by parcel as owners cooperate. Only policies lead to **entrust**, permanent protection under property law. On public land, a line is meant to fund care the land manager agrees to.

When a line or policy exists, you become invested by buying its certificate; the owner and the operator could each buy one, from the asset side and the operating side. The price goes to the account the certificate names, less a small reward share for the minting contract. You hold a share of the certificate, not title to the land; the owner or steward keeps it. Distributions to holders are being built. The live [Roaring Fork River account](/roaring-fork-river.basin?from=guide) covers the whole valley, but no account carries this creek's watershed on its own, and no line exists; one [could be suggested under it](/specific/create?mode=suggest&agent=roaring-fork-river.basin&name=East%20Snowmass%20Creek%20watershed&from=guide). **ensurance** is not insurance and pays no claim ([what ensurance cannot do](/guide/what-ensurance-cannot-do?from=guide)).

## start with your own books

1. Name your books: owner, operator, insurer or lender.
2. Name the item the land moves for you: value, days open, claims or collateral.
3. Find who else keeps books on the same land, and what each already pays for.

How this reads for a [company that operates in a place](/solutions/corporations?from=guide&topic=how-far-the-line-goes), an [investor who owns or lends on buildings](/solutions/investors?from=guide&topic=how-far-the-line-goes), or an [insurer](/solutions/insurers?from=guide&topic=how-far-the-line-goes). Or [talk to someone who can help](/contact?from=guide&topic=how-far-the-line-goes).

## frequently asked questions

### what is a split incentive?

When the one who decides on an improvement is not the one who pays the energy bill it would lower: the landlord buys the equipment, the tenant pays the bill.

### who should pay, the landlord or the tenant?

Both could, each from its own books, each share capped by that party's own avoided loss, and no loss counted twice.

### can an owner and a tenant share the cost of keeping land?

Yes. Green leases already reallocate costs and savings for efficiency. For land, owner and operator, and perhaps their insurer and lender, could each buy a certificate on a line for the same place.

## sources

[Aspen Journalism, "Snowmass seeking water from the Roaring Fork River for backup supply" (Brent Gardner-Smith, 2019-01-02, updated 2021-02-19)](https://www.aspenjournalism.org/2019/01/02/snowmass-seeking-water-from-the-roaring-fork-river-for-backup-supply/) — District manager Kit Hamby: about 96 percent of daily water from the East Snowmass Creek diversion; the Ziegler Reservoir expansion cost $10.7 million, with $3.75 million from Aspen Skiing Co.; Ziegler now supplies snowmaking; the Roaring Fork backup right, filed 2017-12-31, as "an insurance policy for the district." Figures are the manager's, as reported; the district's own documents were not opened.

[Aspen Journalism, "Snowmass Village's wilderness water source poses unique wildfire risk" (Elizabeth Stewart-Severy, 2025-10-22)](https://aspenjournalism.org/snowmass-villages-wilderness-water-source-poses-unique-wildfire-risk/) — The roughly 6-square-mile East Snowmass Creek watershed in the Maroon Bells-Snowmass Wilderness; the intake about 20 feet downstream of the wilderness boundary; everything upstream of the intake is wilderness; draft post-fire debris-flow mapping by Wright Water Engineers; Ziegler as three to six weeks of supply, "a short term tool, and a partial tool"; the engineers' and hydrologist's quotes.

[USDA Forest Service, Maroon Bells-Snowmass Wilderness](https://www.fs.usda.gov/r02/whiteriver/recreation/maroon-bells-snowmass-wilderness) — The wilderness lies in the White River and Gunnison national forests.

[USDA Forest Service, Snowmass Ski Area 2017 Projects (#51020)](https://www.fs.usda.gov/r02/whiteriver/projects/51020) — The ski area operates under a special use permit on the White River National Forest.

[Ungar et al., "Guiding the Invisible Hand: Policies to Address Market Barriers to Energy Efficiency," 2012 ACEEE Summer Study on Energy Efficiency in Buildings](https://www.aceee.org/files/proceedings/2012/data/papers/0193-000214.pdf) — The split-incentive definition, the landlord-tenant case and green leasing.

## the series

**how far the line goes**, season two of [the loss started outside the property line](/guide/the-loss-started-outside-the-property-line)

1. [your business depends on land it isn't invested in](/guide/your-business-depends-on-land-it-isnt-invested-in) (read first)
2. [the land up the road](/guide/the-land-up-the-road)
3. [the city paid after the fire](/guide/the-city-paid-after-the-fire)
4. [the forest is the first net](/guide/the-forest-is-the-first-net)
5. [water that falls across the Divide](/guide/water-that-falls-across-the-divide)
6. [the snow melts early because of desert soil](/guide/the-snow-melts-early-because-of-desert-soil)
7. [a stamp that pays for wetlands a thousand miles away](/guide/a-stamp-that-pays-for-wetlands-a-thousand-miles-away)
8. [two sets of books on one building](/guide/two-sets-of-books-on-one-building)

Season one: [what a source is worth paying for](/guide/what-a-source-is-worth-paying-for) · [how to map what your property depends on](/guide/how-to-map-what-your-property-depends-on)
