---
title: the snow melts early because of desert soil
canonical_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/the-snow-melts-early-because-of-desert-soil
markdown_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/the-snow-melts-early-because-of-desert-soil.md
subtitle: "dust from hundreds of miles away, a river that peaks weeks sooner, and the users who already pay to watch it"
category: ecosystem-services
---

# the snow melts early because of desert soil

*dust from hundreds of miles away, a river that peaks weeks sooner, and the users who already pay to watch it*

The snow above the river melts on a schedule set by soil hundreds of miles away. Sun and warmth set it too, but the soil's part runs to weeks.

**What is dust on snow?** Dust on snow is soil blown off disturbed desert ground that settles on mountain snowpack. The darker surface takes in more sunlight, so the snow melts sooner. For the Upper Colorado River Basin, researchers modeled peak runoff arriving about three weeks earlier under heavier dust, and about 5% less water a year.

Stand at a building in Las Vegas, whose water agency is one of four that pooled money in 2014 to keep water in Lake Mead. A heavily studied patch of the snow upstream, Senator Beck Basin in the San Juan Mountains above Silverton, lies about 425 miles away on a map. The soil that darkens it lies upwind, on the Colorado Plateau and in the Great Basin. Counting the wind's path to the snow and the river's path down, the chain is on the order of 500 miles by our map estimate.

Undisturbed desert ground, with its plants and its surface, held itself in place long before the first dam, and does that work whether or not anyone pays. **[ensurance](/explore?from=guide)** is built to give a living place like that an account, so the ones who rest on it can pay toward its keeping. At this distance that is everyone who draws on the river. The account is not the soil, and no account stops a dust storm or a drought.

![photo by Garrett McQuown (@gertminiac) on unsplash](https://images.unsplash.com/photo-1752067430995-2482fe263c79?w=1200&fit=crop)

## what the dust does to the river

At two research towers in Senator Beck Basin, Skiles and colleagues found dust shortened snow cover by 21 to 51 days across 2005 to 2010. Those are study sites, not every slope.

For the whole river, Painter's team in 2010 modeled the Upper Basin from 1916 to 2003 twice: with today's heavier dust and with the lighter dust of the years before settlement. Under heavier dust, peak runoff at Lees Ferry, Arizona came about three weeks earlier on average, around May 29 rather than June 21. Annual runoff fell by more than a billion cubic meters, about 5% (range 2.3% to 7.6%). These are model estimates.

The US Geological Survey estimates the Upper Basin contributes about 92% of the whole basin's natural streamflow. Melt timing there, measured at Lees Ferry, is the schedule the whole river starts from; reservoirs downstream store and regulate it before it reaches any tap ([protect the top of the watershed](/guide/protect-the-top-of-the-watershed?from=guide)).

## where the dust comes from

Painter's 2010 paper says "the dust loading in the UCRB comes from the disturbed soils in the Colorado Plateau and Great Basin."

It was not always this heavy. San Juan lake sediments show dust about 500% above the late Holocene average after 19th-century settlement (Neff et al. 2008), one range's record, not the whole West. The authors link the rise to settlement-era disturbance, suggesting the expansion of livestock grazing.

Today the dust comes from many kinds of dry ground under many managers. USGS researchers on the Plateau find that roads shed several times more dust per unit area than grazing land, but "due to the relatively small area occupied by roads, grazing lands still produce the vast majority of dust regionally." Dust, the same page says, is "greatly influenced by land-use practices and climate, especially drought."

So the source is a landscape across two dry regions, worked by many hands and swung by drought nobody manages, with no one to blame for it. The remedy is hedged in the science: Painter's team writes that "the potential to reduce dust loading through surface stabilization in the deserts … may represent an important mitigation opportunity." A different dust, from a drying lakebed, is in [Great Salt Lake dust is the lakebed](/guide/great-salt-lake-dust-is-the-lakebed?from=guide).

## who rests on the same soil

The 2010 paper opens by noting that the Colorado River serves 27 million people in seven states and two countries. Reclamation says its Glen Canyon Dam sustains "cities, industries, and agriculture" and that its generators help meet the West's power needs. Ski areas stand on the same snow, though no study we found measures dust's effect on a ski season.

Every one of those users has a stake in the desert soil upwind of the snow. Most are not invested in it yet. At this distance the tie runs through a landscape: no one in Las Vegas can point at one ranch and say that parcel carries their water.

## what the river's users already pay for

The river's users already pay to watch the dust. The Center for Snow and Avalanche Studies runs the Colorado Dust-on-Snow program (CODOS), which checks for dust layers at about a dozen mountain-pass sites and tells water managers how dust is changing the timing and rate of melt.

In 2016 the center asked the Colorado Water Conservation Board for $150,000 toward a three-year budget of $432,000, matched in cash by water districts, Reclamation, Denver Water and the City of Grand Junction. It buys knowledge: when the melt will come.

Separately, on July 30, 2014, Reclamation and four water agencies, Southern Nevada's among them, agreed to pay for water left in the system. They put in $11 million to start. After amendments and added funds, Reclamation's 2021 report puts project costs at about $38 million: $8.5 million in the Upper Basin, and $29.8 million in the Lower, at Reclamation's stated cost, for projects that put water in Lake Mead through 2035. The water went to Lakes Powell and Mead and "will not accrue to the benefit or use of any individual user."

Both are real work; neither was built to pay for keeping the ground the dust blows from. The wider story is in [who pays to protect the Colorado River](/guide/who-pays-to-protect-the-colorado-river?from=guide).

## the way to pay at 500 miles

**How the money moves.** **ensurance** has three instruments. A coin carries a theme, such as wildfire resilience. A certificate is a line or a policy. At 500 miles, what fits is a **line**, a certificate for a distance, region or area no single deed covers: here, the desert soils upwind of the Colorado's snow ([how a line is named](/guide/name-the-line-for-the-buyer-not-the-town?from=guide)). A line is written when a buyer can be named who would hold the whole of it, often the kind of party that already pays for this risk (a water agency on the river); others can join it with any amount. A **policy** is a certificate for one titled parcel whose owner works with ensurance, and it carries everything that parcel provides ([how a policy works](/guide/the-natural-asset-policy-is-where-the-promise-meets-the-deed?from=guide)). A line buys policies within its mandate, parcel by parcel as owners cooperate, so money paid into a far line can reach near land. Only policies lead to **entrust**, permanent protection under property law.

When a line or policy exists, you become invested by buying its certificate. The price goes to the account the certificate names, less a small reward share for the minting contract. You hold a share of the certificate, not title to the land; the owner or steward keeps it. Distributions to holders are being built. The river's live [Colorado River basin account](/colorado-river.basin?from=guide) covers the water, but no account carries the soils the dust blows from, and no line exists; one [could be suggested under it](/specific/create?mode=suggest&agent=colorado-river.basin&name=Colorado%20Plateau%20desert%20soils&from=guide). **ensurance** is not insurance and pays no claim ([what ensurance cannot do](/guide/what-ensurance-cannot-do?from=guide)).

:::johnson
**at 500 miles, everyone who draws on the river shares the stake, so the payment has to be shared too.** No one parcel carries your water. A landscape does, and your part of it is a share.

[see the Colorado River account →](/colorado-river.basin?from=guide)
:::

If you run a utility or a business on the river's water, [talk through the far land you rest on](/contact?from=guide&topic=how-far-the-line-goes), or see how this applies to [utilities](/solutions/utilities?from=guide&topic=how-far-the-line-goes), [corporations](/solutions/corporations?from=guide&topic=how-far-the-line-goes) and [regional collaboratives](/solutions/regional-collaboratives?from=guide&topic=how-far-the-line-goes).

## who already pays, and for what

| | dust on snow, about 500 miles |
|---|---|
| The land, and how far | Disturbed desert soils on the Colorado Plateau and in the Great Basin, upwind of the San Juan snow; that snow lies about 425 miles from Las Vegas, and the chain about 500 (map estimates) |
| What it does at that distance | Held in place, it sheds less dust onto the snow. Disturbed, its dust darkens the snow; researchers estimated peak runoff about three weeks earlier and about 5% less water a year |
| The payment that already exists | Dust monitoring, budgeted at $432,000 over three years in a 2016 grant request (CODOS is funded by water districts and agencies); a 2014 pilot to leave water in Lakes Powell and Mead, which started with $11 million and reached about $38 million in project costs by the 2021 report (Reclamation's stated costs; Lower Basin projects deliver water through 2035). Neither pays for the desert soil |
| Who else rests on the same land | Cities, farms, industry and power users of a river that serves 27 million people; ski areas by reasoning, not measurement |
| The way of paying that fits | A line (certificate on the desert soils), held by a buyer such as a water agency, many small shares; one that could be suggested under the Colorado River basin account |

How a payor would set a ceiling on a share of a far source is in [what a source is worth paying for](/guide/what-a-source-is-worth-paying-for?from=guide).

## frequently asked questions

### what is dust on snow?

Wind-blown desert soil that darkens mountain snowpack so it melts sooner. At research towers in Colorado's San Juan Mountains, dust shortened snow cover by 21 to 51 days over 2005 to 2010 (Skiles et al. 2012).

### where does the dust come from?

From disturbed soils on the Colorado Plateau and in the Great Basin (Painter et al. 2010). Roads shed more dust per acre than grazing land, but grazing land covers far more area, so it gives most of the dust regionally (USGS). Drought raises it.

### who pays to reduce dust on snow?

The payments named here watch the dust rather than reduce it: water users fund CODOS monitoring. The 2014 pilot addresses low reservoirs, not dust. Researchers name stabilizing desert soils as a possible remedy; paying for that across a landscape fits a line that could be suggested, in many small shares.

## sources

[Painter et al. 2010, "Response of Colorado River runoff to dust radiative forcing in snow," PNAS 107(40)](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2951423/) — Peak runoff at Lees Ferry on average 3 weeks earlier under heavier dust (May 29 vs June 21); annual runoff down more than 1.0 billion cubic meters, about 5% (range 2.3–7.6%), traced to increased evapotranspiration; dust from disturbed soils of the Colorado Plateau and Great Basin; the river serves 27 million people in seven states and two countries; surface stabilization "may represent an important mitigation opportunity"

[Skiles et al. 2012, Water Resources Research 48, W07522](https://www.inscc.utah.edu/~campbell/snowdynamics/reading/skiles_etal_2012.pdf) — Dust shortened snow cover by 21 to 51 days at Senator Beck Basin's alpine and subalpine towers, 2005–2010


[Neff et al. 2008, Nature Geoscience 1(3)](https://experts.arizona.edu/en/publications/increasing-eolian-dust-deposition-in-the-western-united-states-li/) — San Juan alpine lake sediments: dust 500% above the late Holocene average after 19th-century settlement; authors suggest expanded livestock grazing

[USGS Southwest Biological Science Center, wind erosion and dust emissions on the Colorado Plateau](https://www.usgs.gov/centers/sbsc/science/wind-erosion-and-dust-emissions-colorado-plateau) — Roads and highly disturbed areas give several times more dust per unit area than grazing lands; because roads occupy little area, grazing lands still produce the vast majority regionally; dust greatly influenced by land use and climate, especially drought

[USGS, Integrated Water Availability Assessments, Upper Colorado](https://www.usgs.gov/mission-areas/water-resources/science/integrated-water-availability-assessments-upper-colorado) — The Upper Basin contributes an estimated 92% of the basin's natural streamflow

[Bureau of Reclamation, Glen Canyon Dam](https://www.usbr.gov/uc/rm/crsp/gc/) — The dam sustains "cities, industries, and agriculture"; its eight generators help meet the West's electrical needs

[Center for Snow and Avalanche Studies, Colorado Dust-on-Snow program](https://snowstudies.squarespace.com) — Dust layers monitored at 10 to 12 mountain-pass sites (the site gives each count); funded by water districts, municipalities, Bureau of Reclamation and the Colorado Water Conservation Board

[Colorado Water Conservation Board, Water Supply Reserve Account application summary, item 19(b), September 2016](https://dnrweblink.state.co.us/CWCB/0/edoc/200299/19%28b%29.pdf) — $150,000 request toward a $432,000 three-year CODOS budget; cash matches from water districts, Reclamation, Denver Water and the City of Grand Junction; USGS in-kind

[Bureau of Reclamation, Pilot System Conservation Program report to Congress, August 2021](https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/programs/PilotSysConsProg/report_to_congressW_appendices2021.pdf) — July 30, 2014 agreement; $11 million to start; about $8.5 million (Upper Basin) and $29.8 million (Lower Basin) project costs, the Lower Basin's 16 projects putting water in Lake Mead by 2035; water for Lakes Powell and Mead, not any individual user

## the series

**how far the line goes**, season two of [the loss started outside the property line](/guide/the-loss-started-outside-the-property-line)

1. [your business depends on land it isn't invested in](/guide/your-business-depends-on-land-it-isnt-invested-in) (read first)
2. [the land up the road](/guide/the-land-up-the-road)
3. [the city paid after the fire](/guide/the-city-paid-after-the-fire)
4. [the forest is the first net](/guide/the-forest-is-the-first-net)
5. [water that falls across the Divide](/guide/water-that-falls-across-the-divide)
6. [the snow melts early because of desert soil](/guide/the-snow-melts-early-because-of-desert-soil)
7. [a stamp that pays for wetlands a thousand miles away](/guide/a-stamp-that-pays-for-wetlands-a-thousand-miles-away)
8. [two sets of books on one building](/guide/two-sets-of-books-on-one-building)

Season one: [what a source is worth paying for](/guide/what-a-source-is-worth-paying-for) · [how to map what your property depends on](/guide/how-to-map-what-your-property-depends-on)
