---
title: the risk factor nobody funds
canonical_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/the-risk-factor-nobody-funds
markdown_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/the-risk-factor-nobody-funds.md
subtitle: "ecosystem collapse is a weak extinction risk by effective altruism's own numbers. it is still what decides how bad a bad year gets"
category: philosophy
---

# the risk factor nobody funds

*ecosystem collapse is a weak extinction risk by effective altruism's own numbers. it is still what decides how bad a bad year gets*

A **global catastrophic risk** is a risk that could seriously harm human well-being on a global scale: a severe pandemic, a very large volcanic eruption, an economic collapse. An **existential risk** is the narrower set that could destroy humanity or permanently close off its long-term potential. Every existential risk is catastrophic. Most catastrophic risks are not existential.

By effective altruism's own numbers, ecosystem collapse sits low on the second list. This post agrees, then uses a third idea from the same literature, the risk factor, to ask what decides how large a catastrophe gets once it has started.

A wetland, a headwater forest, a river and the soil under a harvest keep working whether or not anyone puts them in a risk table. In a bad year they are part of what decides how much of the year lands on people. A funder can run effective altruism's tests on money that reaches one of them at a named place. **ensurance** is how that money gets an account, a public record and a route to the place. It is not the place.

:::johnson
**a risk factor does not end the world. it sets the size of a bad year.**

Ecosystem loss scores low as an extinction risk, and effective altruists are right to say so. It may matter differently as a risk factor, which nobody has scored, and some funders of that margin are leaving.

[see which sectors lean on which living systems →](/exposure?from=guide)
:::

![photo by Barnabas Davoti (@davotibarna) on unsplash](https://images.unsplash.com/photo-1758186377805-8148c7b404c5?ixid=M3w4NjQwMjZ8MHwxfHNlYXJjaHw4fHxmb3Jlc3QlMjBlZGdlJTIwZmFybWxhbmQlMjB2YWxsZXl8ZW58MHwwfHx8MTc5NTE0MjYwOXww&ixlib=rb-4.1.0&w=1200&fit=crop&auto=format)

## two lists, kept apart

The 2008 Oxford volume *Global Catastrophic Risks*, edited by Nick Bostrom and Milan Ćirković, defines them on its companion site as "risks that seriously threaten human well-being on a global scale", with examples running from volcanic eruptions and pandemics to economic collapse. Toby Ord, speaking to 80,000 Hours in March 2020, described an existential risk as a threat that "could lead to the destruction of humanity or humanity's long-term potential."

The split matters for money. A longtermist weights a catastrophe that ends the future far above one civilization recovers from, which is one reason AI risk sits at the top of the community's own priority survey, tied with global health. That is a coherent reading of the numbers.

## the numbers, as effective altruism holds them

In *The Precipice* (2020), Ord puts "other environmental damage", which includes biodiversity loss, at about 1 in 1,000 as an existential risk over the next century. Halstead's 2022 review puts the indirect existential risk from climate change "on the order of 1 in 100,000." 80,000 Hours' climate profile judges biodiversity loss unlikely to collapse civilization.

Take those as stated. Ecosystem loss is not the extinction story, and a post that tells you otherwise with confidence should lose your trust. The argument about the quality of the future a living world supports belongs to [longtermism still needs a living present](/guide/longtermism-still-needs-a-living-present?from=guide). This one is narrower.

## a risk and a risk factor

Ord draws the line himself. A risk is a threat that could cause the catastrophe directly. A **risk factor** is a condition that changes how likely or how large other catastrophes are. His worked example is great power war: he guessed that removing it would cut total existential risk this century by about a tenth. Asked to score climate change the same way, he put its weight as a risk factor at very roughly 0.1% to 1%, which he called a rough guess.

He also warned that risk-factor reasoning can lead people into "generic work on things that everyone regards as important anyway", away from targeted work on a neglected risk. That warning applies here, so the answer has to be specific: a named place, a named mechanism, and a margin that can be shown to be thinning.

Kareiva and Carranza made the ecological version of the argument in a 2018 paper published through Cambridge's Centre for the Study of Existential Risk. In their reading, the larger danger lies in how little anyone understands coupled human and natural systems. [What systemic risk actually is](/guide/what-systemic-risk-actually-is?from=guide) covers the financial side of that kind of cascade.

## where a living system sets the size of the loss

In each case the living system does not cause the catastrophe; it is part of what decides how much of it lands. The size of the effect varies by place, and nobody can rerun a year to measure it.

### food in a bad year

A harvest failure becomes a catastrophe when it hits several regions at once and stores run short. Soil that holds water and the wetland that recharges a well each change how much a dry or hot season takes from a crop. Pollinators change how much it yields in any season. None guarantees a harvest. They move the floor under a bad year, field by field.

### water

Headwater forests and wetlands take in water in a wet season and let it go slowly in a dry one. Floodplains spread high water across their width before it reaches the next town. When they are degraded, the same storm or drought can reach farther downstream and arrive faster. [The loss started outside the property line](/guide/the-loss-started-outside-the-property-line?from=guide) traces one chain from a flooded river valley to a national shortage of a hospital supply. [Resilience means to leap back](/guide/resilience-means-to-leap-back?from=guide) covers the ecologist's meaning of absorbing a shock.

### spillover

Dobson and colleagues, writing in *Science* in 2020, estimated that $22 billion to $31 billion a year of prevention, including up to $9.6 billion to halve tropical deforestation in critical areas, would cost about 2% of what COVID-19 cost. Colin Carlson, quoted as a skeptic in the same coverage, answered that deforestation and the wildlife trade "cause spillover, but they don't cause pandemics." Both can hold. Land use changes how often a pathogen meets a person; what follows depends on health systems, travel and chance. We found no effective altruist grant aimed at spillover from land use (search, 2026-11-20).

## the margin is getting thinner

Neglectedness is measured at the margin, so it can change while the cause stays the same size, and the non-AI margin is changing quickly. The Survival and Flourishing Fund recommended $34.33 million in its 2025 round, about $29 million of it for AI. ALLFED, the resilient-food group, had relied on that fund as its main funder for years. After a sharp cut, it halved its budget and ran an $800,000 emergency appeal in 2025.

AI safety may well deserve the money it gets. Read the same test from the other side: as funding concentrates on the largest direct risks, resilience work outside AI has lost at least one main funder. That is evidence about that margin in general, not about accounts for places.

Conservation as a whole is not neglected. Giving Green's 2026 biodiversity research counts about $77 billion a year from governments and $27 billion from private investment. What is neglected is narrower: a standing way for the people who depend on one place to put money into its keeping before the bad year, and to see that money arrive.

## what funding a source at a named place does

An account for a place can receive money from anyone, at any size, before anything goes wrong. Its keepers can act under a written mandate, and every payment in and out sits on a public ledger. An account can pay out on a funded release schedule, from three months to 512 years; twelve were funded on 2026-11-20. For the four certificates that name the Arno River, wildlife corridors, elk range and a flyway, the mint price goes to the account each names. [arno-river.basin](/arno-river.basin?from=guide) and [inland-wetlands.ensurance](/inland-wetlands.ensurance?from=guide) are two live accounts you can read.

Money reaches the account. Keepers can spend it on the place's condition under the mandate. Condition held over years is part of what decides how much of a dry season, a flood or a spillover reaches the people downstream. A grant ends when it is spent. An account keeps receiving, and for a risk factor that matters, because the condition that sizes a bad year is built in the ordinary years before it.

The people with the most to lose in a bad year are the ones who depend on the place: a water utility, an insurer with policies in the basin, a county downstream. They could invest in its condition through its account.

The protocol is pre-seed. On 2026-11-20 it held 2,095 accounts, 26 certificates and 196 coins, with live numbers at `/api/protocol/stats`. Condition evidence on accounts is reported by stewards and is not third-party verified, and payments from the people who depend on a place are the unproven part.

## next

[Nature exposure](/exposure?from=guide) maps which sectors depend on which living systems, which is where a risk factor turns into someone's loss. [A gift, a position or an investment](/guide/a-gift-a-position-or-an-investment?from=guide) sorts which pocket each kind of money comes from and what it gets back. If you fund or advise on a place and want to talk it through, start at [how we work with foundations](/solutions/foundations?from=guide&topic=ea-investment).

## frequently asked questions

### what is a global catastrophic risk?

A risk that could seriously harm human well-being on a global scale, such as a severe pandemic, a very large volcanic eruption or an economic collapse. Existential risks are the subset that could end humanity or permanently curtail its potential.

### is biodiversity loss an existential risk?

By effective altruism's own estimates, probably not directly: Toby Ord puts other environmental damage at about 1 in 1,000 over a century, and 80,000 Hours judges biodiversity loss unlikely to collapse civilization. Its stronger claim to attention is as a risk factor.

### what is a risk factor?

A condition that raises the chance or the size of other catastrophes without causing one itself. Toby Ord's example is great power war; ecosystem loss is a candidate because it shapes how hard food, water and disease shocks land.

## sources

[Global Catastrophic Risks, companion site to Bostrom and Ćirković (eds.), Oxford University Press, 2008](https://www.global-catastrophic-risks.com/) — "risks that seriously threaten human well-being on a global scale." Checked 2026-11-20.

[80,000 Hours podcast #72, Toby Ord on the precipice, published 2020-03-07](https://80000hours.org/podcast/episodes/toby-ord-the-precipice-existential-risk-future-humanity/) — existential risk defined; risk factors; great power war at about a tenth of total risk; climate as a risk factor at roughly 0.1% to 1%; the warning about generic work. Checked 2026-11-20.

[Ord's estimates in *The Precipice* (2020), summarized on the EA Forum](https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/Z5KZ2cui8WDjyF6gJ) — other environmental damage at about 1 in 1,000 over a century.

[Halstead, climate change and longtermism, 2022, summary on the EA Forum](https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/rcojG8aZhDjFfBBfZ) — indirect existential risk from climate "on the order of 1 in 100,000."

[80,000 Hours, climate change problem profile](https://80000hours.org/problem-profiles/climate-change/) — biodiversity loss unlikely to collapse civilization.

[Kareiva and Carranza, "Existential risk due to ecosystem collapse: Nature strikes back", CSER, 2018](https://cser.ac.uk/resources/existential-risk-due-ecosystem-collapse) — ignorance of coupled human and natural systems as the larger risk.

[Science News on Dobson and others, *Science*, 2020](https://www.sciencenews.org/article/coronavirus-covid-19-pandemic-prevention-deforestation-trees) — $22 billion to $31 billion a year of prevention, about 2% of the cost of COVID-19; Colin Carlson's objection.

[Rethink Priorities, EA Survey 2024, on the EA Forum](https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/CKwDgZGLipchAoxtN) — AI risk and global health tied at the top of the community's priorities.

[Survival and Flourishing Fund, 2025 recommendations](https://survivalandflourishing.fund/2025/recommendations) — $34.33 million recommended, about $29 million of it AI.

[ALLFED on the EA Forum, 2025](https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/K7hPmcaf2xEZ6F4kR) — main funder's cut, budget halved, $800,000 emergency appeal.

[Giving Green, biodiversity research launch, 2026-02-24](https://www.givinggreen.earth/post/giving-green-launches-new-biodiversity-research-and-top-biodiversity-nonprofits) — about $77 billion a year from governments and $27 billion private.

[ensurance protocol stats](https://ensurance.app/api/protocol/stats) — 2,095 accounts, 26 certificates, 196 coins, 12 funded release schedules, read 2026-11-20.

[ensurance certificates](https://ensurance.app/api/specific/tokens) — the certificates and the accounts each names, read 2026-11-20.

## the series

1. [the test most impact investing fails](/guide/the-test-most-impact-investing-fails?from=guide)
2. [importance, tractability, neglectedness: scoring a living place](/guide/importance-tractability-neglectedness-for-a-living-place?from=guide)
3. [would it have happened anyway?](/guide/would-it-have-happened-anyway?from=guide)
4. [give now, give later, or fund something that keeps receiving](/guide/give-now-or-give-later?from=guide)
5. [effective altruists invented the impact certificate](/guide/effective-altruists-invented-the-impact-certificate?from=guide)
6. [the moral circle has no bank account](/guide/the-moral-circle-has-no-bank-account?from=guide)
7. [the risk factor nobody funds](/guide/the-risk-factor-nobody-funds?from=guide)
8. [a gift, a position or an investment](/guide/a-gift-a-position-or-an-investment?from=guide)

The giving side of the same question: [the gift isn't finished when the deduction posts](/guide/the-gift-isnt-finished-when-the-deduction-posts?from=guide).
