---
title: the moral circle has no bank account
canonical_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/the-moral-circle-has-no-bank-account
markdown_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/the-moral-circle-has-no-bank-account.md
subtitle: "the circle of who counts has widened, unevenly, for two centuries. almost nothing in its newest ring can hold a dollar"
category: philosophy
---

# the moral circle has no bank account

*the circle of who counts has widened, unevenly, for two centuries. almost nothing in its newest ring can hold a dollar*

For many groups of people brought inside the circle of who counts, the change came, often late and often incompletely, with the right to own property and hold money in their own names. Past the human line that step has not been taken. A caged hen, a herd on its winter range and a river have all gained advocates. Almost none of them holds a dollar.

**What is moral circle expansion?** Moral circle expansion is the widening, over time, of the set of beings whose interests a society counts: from kin and community to all people, and then, in part, to animals. Effective altruists treat it as a pattern in history and as work still to do, for farmed animals, wild animals and possibly digital minds.

A river, a wetland and a herd keep working whether or not anyone's ethics has made room for them. The circle's question can be put to money: when a dollar is meant for one of them at a named place, who holds it. [**ensurance**](/?from=guide) is how that dollar gets an account, a public record and a route to the place. It is not the place.

:::johnson
**standing without an account is a right nobody can pay.**

Every widening past the human line has put the new member in someone else's budget. An account addressed to a place can receive, hold and pay under a published mandate, with every movement on a public record. 2,095 exist on 2026-11-20.

[see the accounts that exist →](/agents?from=guide)
:::

![photo by Katherina Lipatnikova (@kate_lipa) on unsplash](https://images.unsplash.com/photo-1791059679809-3d67fb67e2f5?ixid=M3w4NjQwMjZ8MHwxfHNlYXJjaHw3fHxjYXJpYm91JTIwaGVyZCUyMHR1bmRyYXxlbnwwfDB8fHwxNzk1MTQyNjc1fDA&ixlib=rb-4.1.0&w=1200&fit=crop&auto=format)

## moral circle expansion in its own terms

The idea is best known from Peter Singer's *The Expanding Circle*, first published in 1981. In his publisher's summary, altruism began as a drive to protect kin and community and became a chosen ethic with "an expanding circle of moral concern." The publisher puts the book's claim plainly: "it is our capacity for reasoning that makes moral progress possible."

The record is uneven. Over the last two centuries the direction is still plain enough: laws in many countries came to protect people once held as property, married women and children, and then, in part, animals.

Effective altruism turned the idea into a question about the marginal dollar, and followed it to three edges. The first is farmed animals. By the end of July 2026, donors tied to the AI industry had given roughly $40 million that year to farm animal welfare, according to Lewis Bollard, who leads that work at Coefficient Giving (Fortune, 2026-07-30). The second is wild animals, where the work is mostly research and Wild Animal Initiative is its home. The third is digital minds. 80,000 Hours calls understanding their moral status "a top emerging priority", with a great deal of uncertainty attached.

## what every widening has in common

This community moves money when the circle moves. Look at what each new member received, and where the money sits.

| who is at the edge | what the widening gave | who holds the money |
|---|---|---|
| Farmed animals | Campaigns, corporate pledges, welfare laws | Advocacy groups and their funders |
| Wild animals | A research field | Research groups and their funders |
| A river with legal personhood | Standing in court, through appointed guardians | Usually no one |
| Digital minds | An open question, taken seriously | No one yet |

In each row the new member has standing in someone else's budget. An advocate raises the money, holds it and decides how to spend it on the member's behalf. The being itself holds nothing. This is no criticism of advocates: a hen cannot sign, and someone has to act.

Rivers show the gap most clearly. Legal personhood, where a parliament or a court has granted it, gives a river standing in court through people appointed to act for it ([what the law will let a place be](/guide/what-the-law-will-let-a-place-be?from=guide) has the cases). Standing usually arrives without an account. The best-known exception shows how hard one is to get: the settlement that made Te Awa Tupua, the Whanganui River from the mountains to the sea, a legal person in New Zealand also set up a NZ$30 million fund "held in the name of Te Awa Tupua". It came out of more than a century of claims by Whanganui iwi, a deed of settlement in 2014 and an act of parliament. It is their achievement and not a template for anyone, including us. [What a river does with an account](/guide/what-a-river-does-with-an-account?from=guide) reads the difference between standing and a ledger.

A member can be counted, argued for and represented in court, and still have nowhere for money to arrive addressed to it.

## what an account changes

An account is a small thing beside a statute. It gives a place no standing and no rights. It does not make a river a legal person or a sentient one, and it does not claim to speak for a river. It does one job: money meant for a place has somewhere to be.

Concretely, an ensurance account can:

- receive from anyone, at any size, at any time
- hold what arrives, apart from every other account and from ours
- pay out under a mandate its keepers write and publish
- show every movement on a public ledger

On 2026-11-20 there were 2,095 of them, for places, purposes and groups of people. [arno-river.basin](/arno-river.basin?from=guide) is one for a river. [elk.syndicate](/elk.syndicate?from=guide) is one for a herd's range, and [flyway.syndicate](/flyway.syndicate?from=guide) is one for a route many species use. Four certificates, the ones that name a river, a wildlife corridor, elk and a flyway, pay their mint price to the account each names. The pockets that money can come from, and what each gets back, are set out in [a gift, a position or an investment](/guide/a-gift-a-position-or-an-investment?from=guide).

With an account, "who funds this river" becomes a lookup. "What is the money for" is answered by a mandate anyone can read.

Anyone who has funded an advocate for a being that cannot ask has already accepted that money can be held for a non-human. An account takes that premise one step further and puts the member's address on it. [Can an animal have a bank account](/guide/can-an-animal-have-a-bank-account?from=guide) covers the older legal version of the same move.

## what an account does not settle

Keepers are people. A river cannot sign, so named people hold an account's key and act under its mandate. Early in the build, most accounts are kept by the team that set them up, and many mandates are still to be written. A membership body that could hold keepers to a mandate in law is planned and has not been formed. Until it is, the written mandate and the public record are what bind them. The protocol is pre-seed, and its live numbers are published at `/api/protocol/stats`.

## the objection from wild animal welfare

One objection comes from inside the circle, and it deserves its strongest form.

Part of this community holds that most wild animals live short lives dominated by suffering. If that is right, more habitat means more of those lives, and a world with more of them may hold more suffering, not less. On this view biodiversity and welfare are different goals. As one EA Forum thread puts it, "The welfare of wild animals is basically orthogonal to biodiversity."

We do not settle that, and an account does not settle it either. A mandate is written by an account's keepers and published, so an account can be held to welfare as plainly as to habitat. A reader who holds the welfare view firmly may decide not to fund an account for habitat. That is a coherent position, and this post does not argue against it.

## if you build agents

Software agents were given wallets and pay-per-request rails over the past year or so. On the same kind of public ledger, places have accounts too. [Every agent got a wallet. The earth didn't](/guide/every-agent-got-a-wallet-the-earth-didnt?from=guide) has the anatomy. Any wallet can send to a place's account, including one a software agent holds. If the question is whether this is crypto: it is a public ledger anyone can read, with a service running the rules on top. What a digital mind is owed is an open question. Whether an account can be addressed to a non-human and kept for it already has a working answer, built for a river and a herd.

## where to go next

The next post takes a different objection at full strength: ecosystem loss is a weak extinction risk by effective altruism's own numbers. Read [the risk factor nobody funds](/guide/the-risk-factor-nobody-funds?from=guide). To check this one, open the [accounts that exist today](/agents?from=guide) and read a mandate and a ledger yourself.

## frequently asked questions

### what is moral circle expansion?

Moral circle expansion is the widening of the set of beings whose interests a society counts, from kin and community to all people and, in part, to animals. The idea follows Peter Singer's 1981 book *The Expanding Circle*, and effective altruists apply it to farmed animals, wild animals and digital minds.

### can a river or a species hold money?

In most places, no: a river or a species is not a legal person and cannot own, sign or hold title. Money can be held for it, in an account addressed to it and kept by named people under a published mandate, which is what an ensurance account is designed to be.

### does protecting nature help wild animals?

It is disputed. Protecting habitat keeps species and populations going, and part of the effective altruism community holds that many wild animals live short, hard lives, so more habitat is not clearly better for the individuals in it. Biodiversity and welfare are different goals.

## sources

[Princeton University Press, Peter Singer, *The Expanding Circle*](https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691150697/the-expanding-circle) — first published 1981; the publisher's description of the argument. Read 2026-11-20.

[Fortune, 2026-07-30](https://fortune.com/2026/07/30/artifical-intelligence-workers-wealth-influx-rewriting-philanthropy-giving-to-save-factory-farm-animals-openai-anthropic-ipo-wealth/) — roughly $40 million from donors tied to the AI industry to farm animal welfare in 2026, according to Lewis Bollard of Coefficient Giving. Read 2026-11-20.

[80,000 Hours, "Moral status of digital minds"](https://80000hours.org/problem-profiles/moral-status-digital-minds/) — "a top emerging priority". Read 2026-11-20.

[Wild Animal Initiative, 2026 priorities, on the EA Forum](https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/wJnEm7hbKBvDaAa6p) — the research home for wild animal welfare. Read 2026-11-20.

[EA Forum thread on wild animal welfare and biodiversity](https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/pJPaSrQ53teh8qdBM) — "The welfare of wild animals is basically orthogonal to biodiversity." Read 2026-11-20.

[Te Tari Whakatau, Whanganui Iwi (Whanganui River) settlement summary](https://whakatau.govt.nz/te-tira-kurapounamu-treaty-settlements/find-a-treaty-settlement/whanganui-iwi) — Te Korotete, the NZ$30 million fund, "will be held in the name of Te Awa Tupua and administered by Te Pou Tupua." Read 2026-11-20.

[ensurance protocol stats](https://ensurance.app/api/protocol/stats) — 2,095 accounts, 26 certificates, 196 coins, 12 funded release schedules, read 2026-11-20.

[ensurance certificates](https://ensurance.app/api/specific/tokens) — the 26 certificates and what each names, read 2026-11-20.

## the series

1. [the test most impact investing fails](/guide/the-test-most-impact-investing-fails?from=guide)
2. [importance, tractability, neglectedness: scoring a living place](/guide/importance-tractability-neglectedness-for-a-living-place?from=guide)
3. [would it have happened anyway?](/guide/would-it-have-happened-anyway?from=guide)
4. [give now, give later, or fund something that keeps receiving](/guide/give-now-or-give-later?from=guide)
5. [effective altruists invented the impact certificate](/guide/effective-altruists-invented-the-impact-certificate?from=guide)
6. [the moral circle has no bank account](/guide/the-moral-circle-has-no-bank-account?from=guide)
7. [the risk factor nobody funds](/guide/the-risk-factor-nobody-funds?from=guide)
8. [a gift, a position or an investment](/guide/a-gift-a-position-or-an-investment?from=guide)

The giving side of the same question: [the gift isn't finished when the deduction posts](/guide/the-gift-isnt-finished-when-the-deduction-posts?from=guide).
