---
title: the forest is the first net
canonical_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/the-forest-is-the-first-net
markdown_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/the-forest-is-the-first-net.md
subtitle: "rockfall, a canyon interstate, and the country that pays for slope forest as infrastructure"
category: natural-capital
---

# the forest is the first net

*rockfall, a canyon interstate, and the country that pays for slope forest as infrastructure*

A **protection forest** is a forest on a slope whose trees stand between a hazard and the people or roads below it. Trunks and roots catch falling rock, hold snow in place and slow loose ground before it reaches a road, a railway or a village.

Stand at a warehouse in a Western Slope town in Colorado. Much of what reaches it comes over Interstate 70, which east of Glenwood Springs runs through Glenwood Canyon, beside the Colorado River and the railway. What matters is the slope directly above the road. That slope may be a few miles from the warehouse or a few hundred, and gravity carries the effect. A rock lets go, follows the fall line, and either stops on the slope or lands on the road.

That slope held rock before the interstate was built and holds it whether or not anyone pays. Everyone who drives, ships or rides through the canyon has a stake in it. Most are not invested in it yet. **[ensurance](/risk-resilience.ensurance?from=guide)** is built to give a living slope an account, so the ones who rest on it can pay for its keeping. The account is not the slope, and no account stops a rock.

:::johnson
**after the fire, federal relief and CDOT funds paid for fences. the slope above them has no line yet.** Switzerland pays for slope forest as infrastructure, alongside its barriers.

[see the risk resilience account →](/risk-resilience.ensurance?from=guide)
:::

![photo by Peter Robbins (@prphotography262) on unsplash](https://images.unsplash.com/photo-1661305780815-c12b004b9861?w=1200&fit=crop)

## what a slope forest does to a falling rock

On a forested slope a falling rock meets trunks, roots and fallen logs. Some rocks stop; others arrive slower and with less force.

Swiss researchers simulated this on a virtual slope. Rockfall frequency below forest fell by roughly 10 to 90 percent against a bare slope, and intensity by 10 to 70 percent. A forest helps most with the many smaller rocks and least with the rare large ones.

*The forest on the slope is the first net.*

It is not the only one. A large boulder or a debris flow can overrun any stand of trees, and a burned slope has lost much of its catch. What a healthy forest does is work every ordinary year, on much of the rock that falls.

## the canyon, the fence and the bill

According to the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA), about 17,000 vehicles a day use the corridor, some 2,200 of them trucks. When the canyon closes, the northern route that the Colorado Department of Transportation (CDOT) recommends adds about two and a half hours.

In August 2020 the Grizzly Creek Fire burned more than 32,000 acres and closed the interstate for two weeks. FHWA reports that the fire and the debris flows after it required over $11 million in repairs. CDOT then put in a temporary barrier on the burn scar and new fences at mileposts 121 and 123. The fencing was estimated at $2,692,000, and CDOT's analysis put its five-year benefit-to-cost ratio at 6.01, counting the highway owner's costs only and not drivers' detours. FHWA approved federal Emergency Relief funding for it, and CDOT added its own money to extend it.

One line in that analysis is worth reading twice. It assumed that the chance of rockfall would fall 20 percent each year "as slopes re-establish stability and vegetation", and the temporary fence is due to come down "once vegetation is re-established on the burn scar". The highway's own numbers already count the slope's recovery. In what we read, nothing pays for its keeping.

In July 2021 intense rain sent mudslides and debris flows across the canyon, larger than the new fencing was designed for, and destroyed part of it. The interstate closed for about two weeks; CDOT later put it at nearly 20 days. The trains stopped too: Amtrak canceled its California Zephyr through the canyon in both directions. Colorado asked FHWA for $116 million in emergency relief, which CDOT called an estimate; about $54 million of it was for repair, debris removal, geohazard work and engineering.

None of this says a forest would have kept the road open. Those debris flows followed a large fire and extreme rain, and the fences were right to be there. CDOT did hard work under pressure. The narrower point: the fences and the slope do parts of the same job, and only the fences were costed in the analysis we read. For a 2026 closure near Silt, see [the highway closed because the watershed didn't](/guide/i-70-flood-closure-watershed-resilience?from=guide).

## the country that already pays for it

Switzerland treats slope forest as infrastructure. About 49% of its forest, some 585,000 hectares, meets the national criteria for protection forest. A 2014 overview from Swiss forest researchers put funding for its care at about CHF 150 million a year, from the Confederation, the cantons and the beneficiaries together, and its authors judged care about ten times cheaper than built protection. In 2020 the Confederation and cantons actually paid out just over CHF 160 million.

Each study figure below is an estimate:

- **Forest against nets.** Over 100 years, one Swiss rockfall study put the net present value of a protection forest at +CHF 162,400 a hectare and of nets at the same site at −CHF 124,100 a hectare.
- **The Gotthard motorway.** Along the A2 between Gurtnellen and Wassen, the study models a risk reduction of CHF 500 to 5,000 a hectare a year; modeled risk would rise by up to 150% without the forest.
- **Martigny, in Valais.** Above a road, a railway and houses, a modeled risk reduction of about CHF 1,350 a hectare a year. "Without forest, the risk would be five times as high."
- **An avalanche gap above Andermatt.** In one engineering estimate for a hypothetical 1.15-hectare windthrow gap, forest care (cutting and silviculture) came to CHF 35,000 a hectare; barriers came to CHF 100,000 to 1,020,000 a hectare, each including replanting and upkeep. One case, from slides.

None of those is a bill. The Swiss bills are the CHF 150 million budgeted and the CHF 160 million paid.

## what has not been done here yet

We found no US study that values a protection forest against a named road. The physics travels; the valuation has not been done. We did not map how much of the canyon slope is forest; parts of it are cliff and recovering burn scar, not the managed stand the Swiss studies value. This post does not guess what these slopes are worth.

## who rests on the canyon slope, and how they could pay

**How the money moves.** **ensurance** has three instruments. A coin carries a theme, such as wildfire resilience. A certificate is a line or a policy. The canyon slope has many payors and no single deed, so what fits is a [line](/guide/name-the-line-for-the-buyer-not-the-town?from=guide), a certificate for a distance, region or area: here, the slopes along the I-70 corridor through Glenwood Canyon. A line is written when a buyer can be named who would hold the whole of it, often the kind of party that already pays for this risk (a road authority); others, such as corridor towns, freight carriers and the railway, can join it with any amount. A [policy](/guide/the-natural-asset-policy-is-where-the-promise-meets-the-deed?from=guide) is a certificate for one titled parcel whose owner works with ensurance, and it carries everything that parcel provides. A line buys policies within its mandate, parcel by parcel as owners cooperate. Only policies lead to **entrust**, permanent protection under property law.

When a line or policy exists, you become invested by buying its certificate. The price goes to the account the certificate names, less a small reward share for the minting contract. You hold a share of the certificate, not title to the land; the owner or steward keeps it. Distributions to holders are being built. No live account carries the corridor's slopes, and no line is minted; one could be suggested: [co-create an I-70 Glenwood Canyon corridor line](/specific/create?mode=suggest&agent=risk-resilience.ensurance&name=I-70%20Glenwood%20Canyon%20corridor&from=guide).

**ensurance** is not insurance and pays no claim when a road closes ([what ensurance cannot do](/guide/what-ensurance-cannot-do?from=guide)). It is built to fund the keeping of the slope, next to the fences.

For a road, port or rail operator, see [infrastructure operators](/solutions/infrastructure-operators?from=guide&topic=how-far-the-line-goes); for a public body, see [governments](/solutions/governments?from=guide&topic=how-far-the-line-goes); or [contact us](/contact?from=guide&topic=how-far-the-line-goes).

## who already pays, and for what

| | I-70 through Glenwood Canyon |
|---|---|
| The land and how far it is | The slope directly above the road, in the canyon east of Glenwood Springs; a few miles from the warehouse or a few hundred |
| What it does at that distance | Where trees and vegetation stand on the slope, they can catch or slow falling rock before it reaches the road; CDOT's analysis assumes less rockfall as vegetation returns |
| The payment that already exists | CDOT with federal Emergency Relief: over $11 million in repairs after the 2020 fire (spent); about $2.7 million of rockfall fencing (estimated cost, federally funded in part, with CDOT's own money added); a $116 million relief request after 2021 (requested, an estimate). It pays for repair, debris removal, studies and alternate routes, not the slope's keeping |
| Who else rests on the same land | About 17,000 vehicles a day, 2,200 of them trucks; the railway and the passenger trains on it; the towns on the corridor |
| The way of paying that fits | A line (certificate on the corridor), held by a buyer such as a road authority, with towns, freight and the railway joining in any amount; one that could be suggested |

What a source like this is worth paying for, and how to split it, is the question in [what a source is worth paying for](/guide/what-a-source-is-worth-paying-for?from=guide).

## frequently asked questions

### what is a protection forest?

A protection forest is a forest on a slope that shields people, roads, railways or buildings below it from natural hazards such as rockfall, avalanches and debris flows. About 49% of Switzerland's forest meets the national criteria for one.

### does a forest stop rockfall?

It can stop many rocks and slow others, but not all. In Swiss simulations, rockfall frequency below forest fell by roughly 10 to 90 percent against bare slopes. Large rocks and gappy stands are why nets and fences are still needed.

### who pays for protection forests in Switzerland?

The Confederation, the cantons and the beneficiaries of the protection: about CHF 150 million a year in a 2014 overview.

## sources

[FHWA, Emergency Relief Program Resilience Case Study, Colorado: Reducing Risk through Rockfall Mitigation, FHWA-HIF-23-029 (2023)](https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/programadmin/er/er_case_colorado_grizzlycreek.pdf) — Fire over 32,000 acres and a two-week closure in 2020; over $11 million in repairs; fencing estimated at $2,692,000; benefit-to-cost 6.01 over five years, owner costs only; assumed 20% yearly fall in rockfall likelihood as slopes re-establish vegetation; fences at mileposts 121 and 123; July 2021 debris flows destroyed some fencing

[Transport Topics, "Interstate 70 in Colorado Partially Reopens" (August 16, 2021)](https://ttnews.com/articles/interstate-70-colorado-partially-reopens) — FHWA figure of 17,000 vehicles a day, some 2,200 of them trucks

[CDOT, "Safety closure in place for I-70 Glenwood Canyon due to high potential of flash flooding" (July 2021)](https://www.codot.gov/news/2021/july-2021/i70-closure-in-place) — The northern alternate route adds about two and a half hours

[CDOT, "Polis Administration Seeks $116 Million in Federal Emergency Aid" (August 9, 2021)](https://www.codot.gov/news/2021/august-2021/polis-seeks-federal-aid-glenwood-canyon) — The $116 million request, an estimate, and its breakdown

[CDOT, "CDOT representatives and agency partners deliver Glenwood Canyon update" (April 2022)](https://www.codot.gov/news/2022/april/cdot-and-agency-partners-deliver-glenwood-canyon-update) — July 2021 mudslides closed I-70 for approximately two weeks

[CDOT, "From Ashes to Asphalt: Glenwood Canyon Recovery" mini-documentary release (July 30, 2026)](https://www.codot.gov/news/2026/july2026news/historic-glenwood-canyon-recovery-mini-documentary) — The 2021 debris flow closed the highway for nearly 20 days

[CBS Colorado, "Glenwood Canyon mudslides cancel Amtrak's California Zephyr" (August 1, 2021)](https://www.cbsnews.com/colorado/news/glenwood-canyon-mudslides-cancel-amtrak-train) — The train runs the length of the canyon beside the Colorado River; service canceled in both directions

[Hess and Denzler, "Schutzwald in der Schweiz", Waldwissen/WSL (2014)](https://www.waldwissen.net/de/lebensraum-wald/schutzfunktion/schutzwald-in-der-schweiz) — About 49% of Swiss forest, some 585,000 hectares, is protection forest; about CHF 150 million a year from the Confederation, cantons and beneficiaries; care about ten times cheaper than built works

[Brantschen, "Sicherstellung der Waldleistungen", Waldwissen (2024)](https://www.waldwissen.net/de/waldwirtschaft/sicherstellung-der-waldleistungen-welche-finanzierungsmoeglichkeiten-gibt-es) — Just over CHF 160 million paid by the Confederation and cantons in 2020

[Moos et al., "Economic valuation of ecosystem-based rockfall risk reduction considering disturbances and comparison to structural measures", Science of the Total Environment (2019)](https://archive-ouverte.unige.ch/unige:145319) — Net present value of +CHF 162,400 a hectare for the protection forest and −CHF 124,100 a hectare for nets

[Moos and Dorren, "Cost-Benefit Analysis as a Basis for Risk-Based Rockfall Protection Forest Management", IntechOpen (2021)](https://arbor.bfh.ch/bitstreams/5979ac39-c711-4977-8704-b4ae14414d35/download) — Gotthard A2: risk reduction of CHF 500 to 5,000 a hectare a year; risk up to 150% higher without the forest

[Moos, Guisan, Randin and Lischke, "Climate Change Impacts the Protective Effect of Forests: A Case Study in Switzerland", Frontiers in Forests and Global Change (2021)](https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/forests-and-global-change/articles/10.3389/ffgc.2021.682923/full) — Martigny: about CHF 1,350 a hectare a year; without forest, risk five times as high

[Moos, Dorren and Stoffel, "Quantifying the effect of forests on frequency and intensity of rockfalls", Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences (2017)](https://nhess.copernicus.org/articles/17/291/2017/) — Simulated reductions of about 10 to 90% in frequency and 10 to 70% in intensity below forested slopes

[Olschewski, "Valuation of Avalanche Protection by Forests", WSL slides, Andermatt case study](https://heg.hesge.ch/media/2432) — Forest care CHF 35,000 a hectare against CHF 100,000 to 1,020,000 a hectare for barriers, including replanting and upkeep, for one 1.15-hectare windthrow gap

## the series

**how far the line goes**, season two of [the loss started outside the property line](/guide/the-loss-started-outside-the-property-line)

1. [your business depends on land it isn't invested in](/guide/your-business-depends-on-land-it-isnt-invested-in) (read first)
2. [the land up the road](/guide/the-land-up-the-road)
3. [the city paid after the fire](/guide/the-city-paid-after-the-fire)
4. [the forest is the first net](/guide/the-forest-is-the-first-net)
5. [water that falls across the Divide](/guide/water-that-falls-across-the-divide)
6. [the snow melts early because of desert soil](/guide/the-snow-melts-early-because-of-desert-soil)
7. [a stamp that pays for wetlands a thousand miles away](/guide/a-stamp-that-pays-for-wetlands-a-thousand-miles-away)
8. [two sets of books on one building](/guide/two-sets-of-books-on-one-building)

Season one: [what a source is worth paying for](/guide/what-a-source-is-worth-paying-for) · [how to map what your property depends on](/guide/how-to-map-what-your-property-depends-on)
