---
title: the city paid after the fire
canonical_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/the-city-paid-after-the-fire
markdown_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/the-city-paid-after-the-fire.md
subtitle: "Glenwood Springs, its intakes below the Grizzly Creek burn, and the other side of the same bill"
category: ecosystem-services
---

# the city paid after the fire

*Glenwood Springs, its intakes below the Grizzly Creek burn, and the other side of the same bill*

On August 10, 2020, the Grizzly Creek Fire started in Glenwood Canyon, Colorado. By the state water board's account three months later, it had burned "an area encompassing much of the City's primary water supply watersheds". Glenwood Springs, whose water system serves about 10,000 residents, drinks mainly from two creeks east of town, No Name Creek and Grizzly Creek. The fire burned the slopes above both.

**How does wildfire affect drinking water?** When a fire burns the slopes above a water supply, rain runs off faster and carries ash, soil and debris into the creeks. The United States Geological Survey (USGS) lists the results: poorer water quality, lost reservoir storage and "increased treatment costs for drinking water providers."

This post stands at one distance: the top of the city's own watershed. The forested slopes above No Name and Grizzly creeks gathered water long before the city laid a pipe, and do that work whether or not anyone pays. **[ensurance](/clean-water.ensurance?from=guide)** gives a living place like that an account, so the ones who rest on it can pay for its keeping. The account is not the forest, and no account stops a fire.

:::johnson
**the city has a stake in the slopes above its intakes. so does everyone who rests on them.** Find the land above your water, and see who else depends on it.

[See the map →](/explore?from=guide)
:::

![photo by Jasper Gribble (@jaspergribble) on unsplash](https://images.unsplash.com/photo-1727659346634-cc26eb81a590?w=1200&fit=crop)

## the slopes above the intakes

A diversion on Grizzly Creek moves water into No Name Creek. A second diversion sends the combined flow into a tunnel and a pipeline to the treatment plant. In 2020 the city manager described the intake works as set back "a little over three and a half miles up the mountain." A pumped supply from the Roaring Fork River was the backup.

The carrier at this distance is water moving downhill. Early projections by the Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) put No Name and Grizzly creeks at "3–10 years of elevated sediment loading." The water board's memo said that without new works, the sediment "will overload the City's water treatment plant." The fire did not damage the intake. The threat was what the burned slopes would send down next.

## what the city paid after the fire

In September 2020 it asked for $1.15 million from the first round of federal Emergency Watershed Protection funds. Its estimate then for emergency repairs was $10–15 million. One award is on the record: $222,975 in federal grant funding, with a city match of $53,961, to armor the No Name intake. Crews faced its walls with steel plates and armored the creek below.

In November 2020 the Colorado Water Conservation Board (CWCB) took up the city's request for an emergency loan of up to $8 million for the project (plus a 1% fee), a project with a plain name: System Redundancy and Pre-Treatment Improvements. As planned, it added a sediment basin at the creek diversion and let the Roaring Fork backup run every day, not only in an emergency. The $8 million was the cap. The city drew $3.74 million for the project; with the fee, the final loan balance was $3.78 million. Annual payments of about $178,000 run from 2025 to 2051. The Post Independent separately reported $3.2 million of upgrades at the plant and the No Name Tunnel in 2021. Those figures may overlap, so they are not added here.

That is careful post-fire work. The city protected its intake, gave itself a second source and kept treatable water reaching the plant, which is where a city has to act after a fire.

The city paid for the fire after it burned; the slope above the intake is the other side of the same bill. No one has priced that side for these slopes. What is on the record is the city's side: works that were paid for, and a loan it will be repaying until 2051.

## what the slopes do at this distance

A forested slope can help hold soil and let water soak in. The USGS describes what happens when the cover burns: loss of canopy and changed soils send more water over the surface in storms, carrying sediment and ash. The effects have ranged "from no noticeable change to 100-fold increases" in sediment and other constituents.

Care of a slope can change the odds. It does not remove them. The Forest Service's wildfire risk methods say that near communities, "hazardous fuel treatments such as thinning and prescribed fire can help reduce the continuity of fuels." No source we opened says care of these slopes would have stopped the Grizzly Creek Fire, and none should be read that way.

## who else rests on the same slopes

The city is one of many. The same canyon walls stand above Interstate 70, which the fire closed for two weeks in 2020. The next summer, rain on the burn scar sent debris flows onto the highway; that story is [the forest is the first net](/guide/the-forest-is-the-first-net?from=guide). A railroad runs through the canyon. The Colorado River below carries rafters and supplies towns downstream; the City of Rifle, farther down, is the subject of [what source water protection already does for a utility](/guide/what-source-water-protection-already-does-for-a-utility?from=guide).

Most of the burned land is national forest. On September 8, 2020, the federal incident team counted 28,092 of the fire's 32,431 acres as Forest Service land, about 87%. So care of these slopes runs through the White River National Forest. The forest has already finished one post-fire recovery project there, to help burned soils hold moisture.

## a stake in the slopes, and the way to pay at this distance

Everyone who drinks from the city's taps, drives the canyon or floats the river has a stake in these slopes. Most are not invested in the slopes themselves yet. What the city paid arrived after the fire, at the pipe.

**How the money moves.** **ensurance** has three instruments. A coin carries a theme, such as wildfire resilience. A certificate is a line or a policy. Many rest on these slopes and most are public land, so the fit is a **line**, a certificate for a distance, region or area no single deed covers: here, the slopes above the intakes ([how a line is named](/guide/name-the-line-for-the-buyer-not-the-town?from=guide)). A line is written when a buyer can be named who would hold the whole of it, often the kind of party that already pays for this risk (a water utility); others can join it with any amount. A **policy** is a certificate for one titled parcel whose owner works with ensurance, and it carries everything that parcel provides ([how a policy works](/guide/the-natural-asset-policy-is-where-the-promise-meets-the-deed?from=guide)). A line buys policies within its mandate, parcel by parcel as owners cooperate. Only policies lead to **entrust**, permanent protection under property law. On public land, a line is meant to fund care the land manager agrees to.

When a line or policy exists, you become invested by buying its certificate. The price goes to the account the certificate names, less a small reward share for the minting contract. You hold a share of the certificate, not title to the land; the owner or steward keeps it. Distributions to holders are being built. No live account carries these slopes for the people who drink from them, and no line exists here; one [could be suggested under the live wildfire resilience syndicate](/specific/create?mode=suggest&agent=wildfire-resilience.syndicate&name=Glenwood%20Canyon%20slopes&from=guide). **ensurance** [is not insurance](/guide/what-ensurance-cannot-do?from=guide) and pays no claim.

More on the top of a watershed: [how upstream land decides downstream water](/guide/how-upstream-land-decides-downstream-water?from=guide), [protect the top of the watershed](/guide/protect-the-top-of-the-watershed?from=guide) and [source water burns when the meadow dries](/guide/source-water-burns-when-the-meadow-dries?from=guide).

## who already pays, and for what

| | Glenwood Springs, 2020–2024 |
|---|---|
| The land and how far it is | The forested slopes of No Name and Grizzly creeks, above intake works the city places about three and a half miles up the mountain; most of the burned land is White River National Forest |
| What it does at that distance | Can help hold soil and slow runoff above the intakes; after the 2020 burn, NRCS projected 3–10 years of elevated sediment |
| The payment that already exists | Bills paid: $3.74 million drawn for the project on a state emergency loan authorized up to $8 million; final balance $3.78 million with the 1% fee, repaid at about $178,000 a year from 2025 to 2051; a $222,975 federal grant plus a $53,961 city match for the No Name intake. Request: $1.15 million in federal funds. Estimate: the city's 2020 estimate of emergency repairs, $10–15 million |
| Who else rests on the same land | Interstate 70, the railroad in the canyon, river users and towns downstream |
| The way of paying that fits | A line (certificate on the slopes above the intakes), held by a buyer such as a water utility, funding care the land manager agrees to; one that could be suggested, not one that exists |

How an avoided loss sets the most worth paying, and why it is a ceiling and not a price, is the subject of [what a source is worth paying for](/guide/what-a-source-is-worth-paying-for?from=guide). Utilities can start from [the utilities page](/solutions/utilities?from=guide&topic=how-far-the-line-goes), and anyone can [talk with someone](/contact?from=guide&topic=how-far-the-line-goes).

## frequently asked questions

### how does wildfire affect drinking water?

Fire strips the cover that holds soil on a slope, and storms then wash ash, sediment and debris into the creeks a city drinks from. The USGS lists poorer water quality, lost reservoir storage and higher treatment costs. After the 2020 Grizzly Creek Fire, NRCS projected 3–10 years of elevated sediment in Glenwood Springs' two source creeks.

### who pays to protect the forest above a water intake?

On national forest land, the Forest Service plans and carries out the care, through its own budget and programs. After a fire, the utility pays for intake and treatment works, sometimes with state loans and federal grants. Glenwood Springs drew $3.74 million on a state loan and used a $222,975 federal grant to armor its intake.

### what can a small utility do?

Know which land sits above its intakes and who manages it. List who else depends on the same slopes, such as a highway, a railroad or towns downstream. Then it can open that conversation with the land manager ahead of a fire. The cost of that care can be shared among those who rest on the land.

## sources

[Colorado Water Conservation Board, board memo, agenda item 6a, November 18–19, 2020](https://dnrweblink.state.co.us/CWCB/0/edoc/213372/6a.pdf) — The fire start date, the burn across "much of the City's primary water supply watersheds", No Name and Grizzly creeks as the primary supply, the Roaring Fork backup, about 10,000 residents, about 2,200 acre-feet a year, NRCS's 3–10 years of elevated sediment, the project and the loan up to $8 million plus a 1% fee

[Colorado Water Conservation Board, notice of commencement of loan repayment, contract CT2021-3104, June 10, 2024](https://dnrweblink.state.co.us/CWCB/0/edoc/224545/CT2021-3104%20Commence%20Repayment%20Letter.pdf) — Final loan balance $3,777,754.07: $3,740,350.56 disbursed for the project plus a $37,403.51 fee, against a loan contract amount of $8,080,000; first annual payment of $177,891.11 due June 1, 2025; schedule to 2051

[Aspen Public Radio, September 10, 2020](https://www.aspenpublicradio.org/environment/2020-09-10/emergency-funding-for-watershed-protection-headed-to-glenwood-canyon) — The city's $1.15 million request for Emergency Watershed Protection funds, its $10–15 million estimate of emergency repairs, and the intake works "a little over three and a half miles up the mountain"

[Post Independent, June 16, 2021](https://postindependent.com/news/prepared-for-the-future-glenwood-springs-drinking-water-intake-system-at-no-name-creek-reinforced-to-mitigate-damage-from-grizzly-creek-fire-debris-flow) — $222,975 in Emergency Watershed Protection and NRCS funding with a $53,961 city match, steel plates on the intake walls, and $3.2 million of upgrades at the plant and the No Name Tunnel

[United States Geological Survey, water quality after wildfire](https://www.usgs.gov/mission-areas/water-resources/science/water-quality-after-wildfire) — How fire changes runoff, and effects that have ranged "from no noticeable change to 100-fold increases", including higher treatment costs for drinking water providers

[USDA Forest Service, Wildfire Risk to Communities v2, community wildfire risk reduction zones methods, 2024](https://wildfirerisk.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/WildfireRiskToCommunities_V2_Methods_Community-WildfireRiskReductionZones.pdf) — Fuel treatments such as thinning and prescribed fire "can help reduce the continuity of fuels"

[Alaska Incident Management Team, Grizzly Creek Fire incident summary, August 21 to September 8, 2020](https://fire.ak.blm.gov/content/aicc/team_left/03.%20Alaska%20CIMT%20Incident%20Archive/Alaska%20IMT%20Incident%20Summaries/2020%20Summaries/2020%2008-21%20to%2009-08%20Grizzly%20Creek.pdf) — Acres by owner as of September 8, 2020: Forest Service 28,092 of 32,431 (86.65%), Bureau of Land Management 2,426, state 1,908

[USDA Forest Service, White River National Forest, Grizzly Creek Post Fire Recovery](https://www.fs.usda.gov/r02/whiteriver/projects/63790) — A completed project to increase the soil moisture holding capacity of burned soils in the Grizzly Creek, Wagon Gulch and Blue Gulch watersheds

[Federal Highway Administration, Grizzly Creek emergency relief case study, 2023](https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/programadmin/er/er_case_colorado_grizzlycreek.pdf) — The fire burned over 32,000 acres in Glenwood Canyon; the Interstate was closed for two weeks

[CBS Colorado, July 2021](https://www.cbsnews.com/colorado/news/glenwood-canyon-mudslides-damage) — Debris flows in Glenwood Canyon reaching the railroad tracks and the Colorado River

[Colorado Department of Transportation, Glenwood Canyon](https://www.codot.gov/travel/glenwoodcanyon/view) — The Colorado River through the canyon and its rafting

## the series

**how far the line goes**, season two of [the loss started outside the property line](/guide/the-loss-started-outside-the-property-line)

1. [your business depends on land it isn't invested in](/guide/your-business-depends-on-land-it-isnt-invested-in) (read first)
2. [the land up the road](/guide/the-land-up-the-road)
3. [the city paid after the fire](/guide/the-city-paid-after-the-fire)
4. [the forest is the first net](/guide/the-forest-is-the-first-net)
5. [water that falls across the Divide](/guide/water-that-falls-across-the-divide)
6. [the snow melts early because of desert soil](/guide/the-snow-melts-early-because-of-desert-soil)
7. [a stamp that pays for wetlands a thousand miles away](/guide/a-stamp-that-pays-for-wetlands-a-thousand-miles-away)
8. [two sets of books on one building](/guide/two-sets-of-books-on-one-building)

Season one: [what a source is worth paying for](/guide/what-a-source-is-worth-paying-for) · [how to map what your property depends on](/guide/how-to-map-what-your-property-depends-on)
