---
title: pledged is not paid
canonical_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/pledged-is-not-paid
markdown_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/pledged-is-not-paid.md
subtitle: forest and nature funds announce one number and disburse another. count both.
category: nature-finance
---

# pledged is not paid

*forest and nature funds announce one number and disburse another. count both.*

**Results-based payments** are money released only after an agreed result is checked: tonnes of forest emissions avoided, hectares of forest still standing, habitat units delivered. For forests, the largest programs pay a national or state government per verified tonne, or plan to pay per hectare. The number to read is not the pledge. It is what has been paid, to whom, and on what condition.

A forest, a creek, or a herd already has a condition, whether or not anyone pays for it. Outcome-based financing pays only after an agreed result at that place is checked by someone independent. The result is a reading of the place, not the place itself.

That design is the appeal, and it also explains the gap this post is about. A program that pays only after results will always announce its number before it pays it, sometimes by years. The honest way to read any forest or nature fund is to keep two columns side by side, each with a date.

:::johnson
**pledged is not paid. count both, out loud.** — Every program below is real. The headline is the ceiling. The paid column is what has reached the place so far. Ask for both before you plan around either.

[next: paying for a tree that is still alive →](/guide/paying-for-a-tree-that-is-still-alive?from=guide)
:::

## results-based payments in two columns

Six programs, one table. Each row compares like with like as closely as the public sources allow, and each figure carries its date. These are not one market on one scale: four count tonnes of carbon or hectares of forest, two count biodiversity units or land.

| program | announced, committed or available | paid, firm or sold | as of |
|---|---|---|---|
| FCPF Carbon Fund (World Bank) | About $720 million under agreements with 15 countries, for 144 million tonnes | Over $232 million paid, for 46.5 million tonnes; countries had reported more than 131 million tonnes | June 2024 (committed); November 2025 (paid) |
| GCF REDD+ results-based payments pilot | A $500 million envelope at $5 per tonne | $497 million approved across eight projects, for results already achieved between 2014 and 2018; the envelope was used up by the end of 2020 | March 2026 (Climate Funds Update) |
| LEAF Coalition, run by Emergent | Over $1 billion in commitments from more than 30 companies and four governments | Signed agreements to deploy over $300 million across five forest countries and states; we found no published total actually disbursed; Costa Rica's first credits were issued in June 2026 | June 2026 |
| Tropical Forest Forever Facility (TFFF) | About $7.3 billion in sponsor capital announced, against a $10 billion goal for the end of 2026 | About $2 billion counted as firmly committed in November 2025 (Brazil and Indonesia, $1 billion each); experts quoted by Climate Home News do not expect payments to forest countries before 2028 | September 2026 |
| Voluntary biodiversity credits | No single pledge | Monthly sales of about $20,000 (February), $119,000 (June) and $15,000 (July), per Carbon Pulse headlines (paywalled, not read in full); cumulative estimates from about $5.4 million (Bloom Labs, via Seatrees) to about $10 million (Carbon Pulse headline) | 2026 |
| England's biodiversity net gain (BNG), off-site register | About 3,000 hectares of registered off-site land | About 2% (58 hectares) sold to development | data to May 2025 |

Read the table for direction, not for a ranking. The FCPF has paid about a third of what its agreements contract, and it pays as each verified reporting period closes, so the paid column fills in over the life of the agreements. The GCF pilot is the instructive exception: it paid for results that had already happened, so approved and paid sit close together, and the GCF has since moved this kind of payment into its regular funding cycle. LEAF and the TFFF are earlier in their lives. The two biodiversity rows show a different gap: not a check that is slow, but buyers who have not arrived.

## why the gap exists

Four reasons. None of them is a scandal, and each tells you what to ask.

**The check takes time.** A results-based payment waits on a reporting period to close, a monitoring report, an independent verification, and issuance. FCPF countries had reported more than 131 million tonnes by November 2025; 46.5 million had been paid for. A reported tonne is not yet a verified, paid tonne. That lag is the cost of the rigor that makes the money credible in the first place.

**The payer is waiting on its own payer.** In an intermediated deal, the government's buyer is often a seller too. Pará, in Brazil, signed an agreement with Emergent in September 2024 worth up to $180 million at $15 per tonne; Emergent intends to resell the credits to companies and governments. Carbon Pulse has reported that the financing agreement times Emergent's payments to money first arriving from those buyers. In June 2025, Pará's environment secretariat said no funds had yet been disbursed, and federal prosecutors were challenging the deal in court. In a chain like that, the slowest payer sets the pace for the forest.

**The pledge has a condition in it.** For the TFFF, Mongabay reported in September 2026 that Norway's pledge of up to $3 billion is released in full only once sponsor capital reaches $15 billion, the UK's up to $540 million is a loan subject to final terms, and Germany's roughly $1.15 billion is paid over a decade. A conditional pledge is a real promise with a trigger. Counting it as money in hand is the reader's error, not the pledger's.

**The buyer has not arrived.** Biodiversity credit sellers and England's habitat banks have registered supply ahead of the demand so far. A voluntary credit waits on a buyer who chooses to pay; a statutory one waits on development that needs the units. [Demand by statute](/guide/demand-by-statute?from=guide) covers the BNG rule and [what a biodiversity credit actually is](/guide/what-a-biodiversity-credit-actually-is?from=guide) covers the voluntary side.

## the one design that pays for a kept forest

Most results-based payments for forests pay for a change: tonnes of emissions avoided against a baseline. The TFFF is built differently. It proposes to pay tropical forest countries for each hectare of forest still standing, every year, with eligibility tied to low and falling deforestation (per REDD-Monitor) and at least 20% set aside for Indigenous peoples and local communities. The money is meant to come from investing sponsor and private capital, mostly in emerging markets, and paying forest countries out of the returns.

That makes it the closest large-scale precedent for paying a place to stay as it is, which is the part the market rarely funds ([who pays to keep the stand standing](/guide/who-pays-to-keep-the-stand-standing?from=guide)). The rate is the part to hold loosely. A maximum of about $4 per hectare per year has been widely reported; we have not confirmed it against the facility's concept note. In September 2026, one analyst quoted by Mongabay calculated a rate nearer $0.40 per hectare, with at most about $400 million reaching forest countries if markets hold. Both are reported estimates of a fund that has not yet paid. The design is the news; the rate is not settled.

## what to ask of any fund

If you are a foundation officer writing a grant that assumes a results payment will follow, or a ministry counting a per-hectare payment in next year's budget, ask four questions, in this order:

1. **What is announced or committed?** The headline, with its date.
2. **What is firm?** Signed, deposited, unconditional. Name each condition attached to the rest.
3. **What has been paid?** To whom, when, and for which reporting period.
4. **On what condition does the next payment move?** Whose check, whose payment has to land first, and what result triggers it.

Keep the answers as a ledger per payer and per place, and update it when money moves, not when a press release does. A program that can answer all four is easier to plan around than one that can answer only the first, whatever the size of its headline. [Alternatives to carbon credits](/guide/alternatives-to-carbon-credits?from=guide) lays out the other routes a payer can take to a forest.

## the same columns, at the place

The same discipline applies to us. On [**ensurance**](/natural-assets?from=guide&topic=outcome-based-financing), a place can hold an account in its own name, meaning money and records kept under that place rather than under a program. A rule can be written against that place before the season, to pay when a baseline holds or a reading improves. The reading landing on the account and the evidence check are being wired. No reading has moved money yet. Count us the same way: for readings at a place, our paid column is zero. [Holds or improves](/guide/holds-or-improves-outcome-payments-into-the-place?from=guide) covers how such a rule is written.

If you run, fund, or would pay into a results-based program, [tell us](/contact?from=guide&topic=outcome-based-financing) the place, the result you would pay for, who checks it, and who already depends on the place. That is the start of a two-column ledger.

## frequently asked

### what are results-based payments for forests?

Results-based payments for forests are money paid to a country, state or project only after an agreed forest result is independently checked. Most pay per tonne of emissions avoided against a baseline, as the FCPF Carbon Fund and the GCF pilot do. The proposed TFFF would pay per hectare of standing forest instead.

### how much has the fcpf paid?

As of November 2025, the World Bank reported over $232 million in results-based payments from the Forest Carbon Partnership Facility, for 46.5 million tonnes of emission reductions. Its 15 agreements are expected to pay about $720 million in total, for 144 million tonnes, as each reporting period is verified.

### what is the tropical forest forever facility?

The Tropical Forest Forever Facility is a fund launched around COP30 in Brazil to pay tropical forest countries each year for forest kept standing, from returns on invested capital. By September 2026 about $7.3 billion had been announced against a $10 billion goal. Experts quoted by Climate Home News do not expect payments to countries before 2028, and the per-hectare rate is reported, not final.

### why is so little paid?

Because results-based payments come after results, and results take time to verify. Some payers wait on their own buyers to pay first, many pledges carry conditions, and some markets have more sellers than buyers. Ask any fund what is committed, what is firm, what has been paid, and on what condition.

## sources

[World Bank, "Nepal receives $9.4 million for forest carbon credits under the Forest Carbon Partnership Facility", November 2025](https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2025/11/16/nepal-receives-9-4-million-for-forest-carbon-credits-under-the-forest-carbon-partnership-facility) — FCPF paid total, tonnes paid and reported.

[World Bank, "Enabling carbon market development", June 2024](https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2024/06/30/enabling-carbon-market-development) — 15 agreements, about $720 million for 144 million tonnes.

[Green Climate Fund, REDD+ results-based payments pilot](https://www.greenclimate.fund/access-funding/other-funding-options/rfp/redd-plus-pilot) — $500 million envelope, $5 per tonne, eligible results period, envelope exhausted by end of 2020.

[Climate Funds Update, *REDD+ Finance* briefing, March 2026](https://climatefundsupdate.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/CFF5-2026-ENG-DIGITAL.pdf) — eight GCF pilot projects, $497 million approved; ex-post versus ex-ante payment.

[EDF, "Costa Rica becomes the first country in the world to access climate finance through LEAF", June 2026](https://www.edf.org/media/costa-rica-becomes-first-country-world-access-climate-finance-through-leaf) — LEAF commitments and signed agreements.

[Climate Home News, "Pará's Amazon forest carbon deal in doubt as prosecutors move to block it", June 2025](https://www.climatechangenews.com/2025/06/08/paras-amazon-forest-carbon-deal-in-doubt-as-prosecutors-move-to-block-it/) — Pará agreement size, price, no funds disbursed, legal challenge. Payment timing per [Carbon Pulse](https://carbon-pulse.com/468087/) (paywalled; reported, not read in full).

[Mongabay, "Brazil's tropical forest fund races to raise $2.7 billion before deadline", September 2026](https://news.mongabay.com/2026/09/brazils-tropical-forest-fund-races-to-raise-2-7-billion-before-deadline/) — TFFF announced total, goal, pledge conditions, investment model, 20% share, analyst estimate.

[REDD-Monitor, "The Tropical Forest Forever Facility", November 2025](https://reddmonitor.substack.com/p/the-tropical-forest-forever-facility-c2f) — announced versus committed; reported maximum of $4 per hectare per year.

[Climate Home News, "Brazil confident new rainforest fund will reach $10bn donor milestone", September 2026](https://www.climatechangenews.com/2026/09/29/brazil-confident-new-rainforest-fund-tfff-10bn-fund-finance/) — payments not expected before 2028.

Carbon Pulse monthly headlines on voluntary biodiversity credit sales, 2026 ([February, cumulative about $10 million](https://carbon-pulse.com/489959/); [June](https://carbon-pulse.com/529765/); [July](https://carbon-pulse.com/540997/)) — paywalled; headline figures only. [Seatrees, May 2026](https://seatrees.org/blogs/in-the-news/seatrees-emerges-as-a-leader-in-the-global-biodiversity-credit-market), citing Bloom Labs' March 2026 report — about $5.4 million cumulative.

[Oxford Nature Recovery, "Early outcomes of England's new biodiversity offset market"](https://naturerecovery.ox.ac.uk/news/early-outcomes-of-englands-new-biodiversity-offset-market/) — about 2% of the off-site register sold (58 of about 3,000 hectares), data to May 2025.

## the series

1. [what outcome-based financing actually is](/guide/what-outcome-based-financing-actually-is?from=guide)
2. [what an outcome bond investor actually holds](/guide/what-an-outcome-bond-investor-actually-holds?from=guide)
3. [pledged is not paid](/guide/pledged-is-not-paid?from=guide)
4. [paying for a tree that is still alive](/guide/paying-for-a-tree-that-is-still-alive?from=guide)
5. [holds or improves: outcome payments into the place](/guide/holds-or-improves-outcome-payments-into-the-place?from=guide)
6. [the buyer pays for what it depends on. the holder earns from what it holds](/guide/the-buyer-pays-the-holder-earns?from=guide)
