---
title: "no one's land was never empty"
canonical_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/no-ones-land-was-never-empty
markdown_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/no-ones-land-was-never-empty.md
subtitle: terra nullius called lived-on land empty so it could be taken. land held for itself starts from the people and other species already there
category: philosophy
---

# no one's land was never empty

*terra nullius called lived-on land empty so it could be taken. land held for itself starts from the people and other species already there*

"No one's land" is not a new idea. For a long time it was a legal excuse: a way to look at country full of families, law and history, call it empty, and take it. So when this series imagines land owned by no one, it owes a plain answer first. What do we mean, and how is it different?

The country, the water running through it, and the people and other species living there exist whether or not anyone holds a deed or a certificate. [*Ensurance*](/?from=guide) can be one way a place gets paid for and held for itself. It is not the place, and it gives no one a right to it.

**What is terra nullius?** Terra nullius is Latin for "nobody's land". In international law it named territory treated as belonging to no recognised sovereign, which a power could acquire by occupying it. Australian law leaned on it from 1788 to treat a continent already lived on as if no one held it. In 1992 the High Court of Australia overturned that in *Mabo v Queensland (No 2)*.

:::johnson
**owned by no one has to mean held for itself, never empty.**

The people and living things already on a piece of land come first. Anything built here starts from the rights they hold, not from a blank map.

[why community land rights come first →](/guide/community-land-rights-come-first?from=guide)
:::

## the map that was drawn empty

Once a court treated land as unoccupied, the people living on it had no title the court could see. In 1889 the Privy Council described New South Wales as "a tract of territory practically unoccupied, without settled inhabitants or settled law." The place had not changed. The law's eyes had.

Five Meriam people from Mer, Murray Island, in the eastern Torres Strait challenged that view in the High Court of Australia. Queensland argued the islands had become Crown property when annexed in 1879. On 3 June 1992, six of seven judges disagreed. The court recognised the Meriam people's native title to most of their lands on Mer, including the right to possess, occupy, use and enjoy them, and held that native title exists in Australian common law. Eddie Koiki Mabo, the lead plaintiff, had died that January and did not hear it.

The Native Title Act 1993 followed. The court also held that governments could extinguish native title. That history belongs to the Meriam people and to the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples who lived it.

What it shows about a phrase is simple: calling land no one's was how it was taken.

## the commons had an owner too

The English commons is the other old story of land said to have no owner. [Held for itself, used by many](/guide/held-for-itself-used-by-many?from=guide) tells it.

## what we mean instead

So our phrase has to mean something else: held for itself, with the people and other species already there counted first.

| | terra nullius | held for itself, in the design |
|---|---|---|
| Who is already there | Treated as no one | Counted first |
| Existing and customary rights | Ignored | Named first, before anything is conferred |
| Who can take it | Whoever claims it | No one: the holding is locked against sale |
| What the phrase does | Opens land to taking | Closes it to taking |

Where a community already holds, uses or governs land, that hold is the starting point, and the community decides what happens next, inside the law that applies. [Community land rights come first](/guide/community-land-rights-come-first?from=guide) makes the case; [how to fund Indigenous land rights that last](/guide/how-to-fund-indigenous-land-rights-that-last?from=guide) sets out consent as the gate.

One plain limit: land owned by no one is not possible under today's law, where title always sits with some legal holder. [What the law will let a place be](/guide/what-the-law-will-let-a-place-be?from=guide) walks the routes that come closest. And none of this repairs what terra nullius did. What we can do is make sure our own phrase never repeats it.

## what is already built

A place, a purpose or a people can have its own [account](/agents?from=guide): an agent with a wallet. Accounts gather in [groups](/groups?from=guide), and an account can hold certificates, including another place's. A community can set one up for its place and keep it. Early in the build, most accounts are kept by the people who set them up, and a place's account acts through its keepers and its mandate.

Today a certificate is not ownership of land. It grants no title, access, use or governance ([one token can't be your home, your vote and your visit](/guide/one-token-cant-be-your-home-your-vote-and-your-visit?from=guide)), and an account named after a place does not hold its title ([an account cannot protect a watershed by itself](/guide/an-account-cannot-protect-a-watershed-by-itself?from=guide)).

## what we want to build

The direction is a **conferral instrument**: a written legal document in which a land owner or steward confers rights on certificate holders. It could confer ownership, or as an alternative governance rights, use rights, or both. No conferral has been made yet.

The version this post cares about starts from the ground. Before anything is conferred, it names the rights already on the land: living there, fishing, gathering, ceremony, grazing, passage. Those sit above anything a certificate could carry, and the instrument would be written so that no holder receives a right that cuts across them. Where a community holds the land, the community decides whether to confer anything at all.

Next: [one parcel, 23,564 holders](/guide/one-parcel-23564-holders?from=guide) and [when most of the owners are not people](/guide/when-most-of-the-owners-are-not-people?from=guide).

## build it with us

Many tribes, communities and land stewards already hold land outside the fee-simple habit: collective title, customary tenure, community land trusts, land held in trust for a purpose. They are best placed to say whether any of this is worth building, and how.

If that is you, start at [tribes](/solutions/tribes?from=guide&topic=land-owned-by-no-one) or [land stewards](/solutions/land-stewards?from=guide&topic=land-owned-by-no-one), or [tell us what you hold and what you would never give up](/contact?from=guide&topic=land-owned-by-no-one). If the answer is no, that is the answer.

## frequently asked questions

### what does terra nullius mean?

Latin for "nobody's land": territory treated as belonging to no recognised sovereign, open to acquisition by occupation. Australia's colonial law used it to treat inhabited land as empty.

### did the mabo decision end terra nullius?

On 3 June 1992 the High Court of Australia rejected it and recognised native title in common law. The court also held that governments could extinguish native title.

### is land owned by no one the same as empty land?

No. In this series it means land held for itself and never for sale, with the people and other species already there counted first.

### does an ensurance certificate give anyone rights to land?

Not today: no title, access, use or governance. The direction is that a land owner or steward could confer rights in writing, starting from the rights already on the land. No conferral has been made.

## sources

[Australian National University, College of Arts and Social Sciences, "1992 – Mabo v. Queensland"](https://cass.anu.edu.au/news/1992-mabo-v-queensland) — Judgment handed down 3 June 1992; brought by "five Meriam people from Murray Island (Mer) in the eastern Torres Strait"; terra nullius "at the heart of Australian law since 1788"; Queensland's argument that the land became Crown property on annexation in 1879; the court's recognition of the Meriam people's rights to possess, occupy, use and enjoy most of their lands on Mer; the Native Title Act 1993

[Wikipedia, "Mabo v Queensland (No 2)"](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mabo_v_Queensland_(No_2)) — Six-to-one majority (Dawson J dissenting); native title recognised at common law; terra nullius rejected as a bar to recognition; native title can be extinguished by government action; the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) enacted in response

[Wikipedia, "Terra nullius"](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terra_nullius) — Latin for "nobody's land"; territory not belonging to a recognised sovereign acquired through occupation; the Privy Council in *Cooper v Stuart* (1889) on New South Wales as "a tract of territory practically unoccupied, without settled inhabitants or settled law"

[Wikipedia, "Eddie Mabo"](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eddie_Mabo) — Born on Mer; died 21 January 1992, before the decision of 3 June 1992

## the series

1. [land owned by no one](/guide/land-owned-by-no-one?from=guide)
2. [no one's land was never empty](/guide/no-ones-land-was-never-empty?from=guide)
3. [what the law will let a place be](/guide/what-the-law-will-let-a-place-be?from=guide)
4. [one parcel, 23,564 holders](/guide/one-parcel-23564-holders?from=guide)
5. [when most of the owners are not people](/guide/when-most-of-the-owners-are-not-people?from=guide)
6. [what no one can do to it](/guide/what-no-one-can-do-to-it?from=guide)
