---
title: maladaptation moves the harm downstream
canonical_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/maladaptation-moves-the-harm-downstream
markdown_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/maladaptation-moves-the-harm-downstream.md
subtitle: "a seawall that floods the next village, a cooling system that adds the emissions it fights. the fix is to read flows both ways"
category: nature-finance
---

# maladaptation moves the harm downstream

*a seawall that floods the next village, a cooling system that adds the emissions it fights. the fix is to read flows both ways*

**Maladaptation** is adaptation that backfires: a measure meant to lower climate risk that raises it, for the people it protects, for a neighbour, or for everyone later. A seawall can push floodwater onto the next village. A floodplain upstream can hold water and release it slowly, and the town below, which already spends money when floods get through, could invest in keeping it.

The IPCC defines maladaptation as action that may increase the risk of adverse climate-related outcomes, and notes that most of the time nobody intended it. The seawall is the standard example. The check is to follow the water after the measure goes in.

:::johnson
**a wall that floods the next town hasn't reduced the risk. it moved it.** — Judge an adaptation measure by where the harm ends up, not only by what the protected asset no longer feels.

[next: bankable adaptation starts with the people who gain →](/guide/bankable-adaptation-starts-with-a-payer?from=guide)
:::

## what maladaptation means

The IPCC's Sixth Assessment Report glossary defines maladaptive actions as "actions that may lead to increased risk of adverse climate-related outcomes, including via increased greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, increased or shifted vulnerability to climate change, more inequitable outcomes, or diminished welfare, now or in the future." It adds: "Most often, maladaptation is an unintended consequence."

That definition names four routes (more emissions, vulnerability that grows or moves, a less fair outcome, lower welfare) and two tenses, now and later. For this post the important word is **shifted**. A measure can look like a clear gain to the asset it protects and still raise total risk, because part of the harm has gone somewhere the appraisal didn't look. Design, place and timing decide which way a measure lands.

Maladaptation is often a good idea checked in one direction only. If you want the difference between adapting before a hazard and recovering after one, [adaptation and resilience are not the same ticket](/guide/adaptation-and-resilience-are-not-the-same-ticket?from=guide) takes those two words apart.

## two warnings inside a trillion-dollar estimate

McKinsey Global Institute's *Advancing adaptation* (November 2026) costs 20 proven measures against heat, drought, wildfire and flooding at developed-economy protection standards. Protecting everyone exposed today would cost about $540 billion a year, against about $190 billion actually spent. In a world 2°C warmer by 2050, which MGI uses as a planning scenario and not a forecast, the figure is about $1.2 trillion a year.

That number is not a nature market. More than half of it is protection against heat, and active cooling, mostly air-conditioning, is 38% on its own. Nature-based lines (urban trees, fuel management, swales, mangroves) come to roughly a tenth.

MGI gives maladaptation a short passage with two examples, and both deserve more. A seawall or flood defence in one area "may inadvertently increase flood risk elsewhere." Air-conditioning carries "potentially significant emissions associated with energy use and refrigerants." The first moves harm sideways, to the next town. The second moves it forward in time, into the warming behind the next heat wave.

## the seawalls on Vanua Levu

In 2020, Annah Piggott-McKellar, Patrick Nunn, Karen McNamara and Seci Sekinini published a study of two seawall projects built for coastal communities on Vanua Levu, Fiji's second-largest island. The walls were meant to protect against sea-level rise, erosion, tidal flooding and storm surge. The researchers found they had not achieved that aim. Water collected on the landward side, the village side, with the walls "acting more like a dam", which they put down to ineffective design and construction of the walls and the drainage around them. The result was harm to land and livelihood security.

Here the harm landed first on the village the wall was built to protect. GARF 2.0, citing the study, adds that the walls also shifted vulnerability to people and places elsewhere along the coast. Both are the miss MGI warns about: the hazard was read, and the water's path after construction was not. The authors' remedy is not "never build walls". It is site-specific measures planned, built and maintained with the communities' own knowledge leading. This post draws on the researchers' account, not on the villagers' own.

The case now sits in a lender's handbook. Standard Chartered and KPMG's *Guide for Adaptation and Resilience Finance 2.0* (November 2026) notes that the Fiji walls "ended up trapping floodwater" in the villages they were built to protect, and makes avoiding maladaptation and significant harm one of the tests an investment must pass to count as adaptation and resilience finance.

## three directions harm can move

| where the harm goes | example | who carries it | what a one-way check misses |
|---|---|---|---|
| sideways, to a neighbour | a levee or wall that pushes floodwater onto the next town or the opposite bank | people outside the project boundary | the appraisal ends at the project's own boundary |
| back onto the protected | the Vanua Levu walls trapping water on the village side, and shifting vulnerability along the coast | the community the measure was for | the hazard is modelled; the drainage after construction is not |
| forward, into later | cooling that adds emissions; irrigation that, for example, draws down an aquifer the next drought will need | everyone, and the next decade | the benefit is counted this year; the cost arrives in a later one |

Nature-based measures are not exempt. Fast-growing plantations in a dry catchment can reduce the streamflow that farms and towns below depend on. A pond that stores water upstream also stores it from someone downstream. The test is the same for a field as for a wall: where does the flow go next, and who is there?

## why the usual check misses it

A project appraisal usually reads in one direction, from the hazard to the asset it protects. The benefit is the loss avoided inside the boundary. The cost is what the builder pays. Harm outside the boundary appears on neither side of that ledger, so a measure can show a strong benefit-to-cost ratio while it moves risk onto people who never see the appraisal. Economists call that an externality. On a flood map it is simpler: the water went somewhere.

Contrast the ground that does the same job without moving the risk. A floodplain that is allowed to flood can store water and release it slowly, so it can lower the peak downstream rather than relocate it, where it is sited and tested for timing. A street canopy can cool without adding emissions, where the species and the water to sustain it suit the site. That is why the living system so often belongs at the base of an adaptation plan rather than as a planting scheme beside the wall. It is also why [no place is resilient alone](/guide/no-place-is-resilient-alone?from=guide): the region, not the project, is the unit where moved harm shows up.

## how ensurance reads a parcel: every flow carries a sign

**Ensurance** is designed to read a parcel as three things at once: a **source** for others, a **subject** with its own risks, and the ground under whatever use stands on it, whether a factory, a farm or the ecosystem itself. Flows between parcels carry a **sign**. A source can provide (water held back, shade, a stable slope) or harm (sediment from a burned slope, nitrate from a feedlot, heat from pavement, floodwater redirected by a wall). One source can do both on different flows: the farm upstream feeds the town and loads its river. This is the method, and the harm side of it is being built: dependency reads exist for some places today, but the signed, two-way run for a single parcel is not finished, and we have not published one on a named parcel.

The read runs both ways, as described in [every account has two lists](/guide/every-account-has-two-lists?from=guide):

- **From the subject inward:** what reaches this place, helpful or harmful, and from where?
- **From the source outward:** what does this place send, and to whom? A wall's outward list is where "flood risk elsewhere" would appear.

The design rests on three rules:

1. **Never net.** A source's benefit and its harm stay separate lines with their own evidence, so a large benefit can't hide a harm.
2. **The action follows the sign.** A helpful source is protected and kept so it goes on providing. A harmful source is repaired or changed so it stops. "Is it protected?" is the wrong test for the second: a protected forest that has burned still sends sediment.
3. **Evidence travels with the claim.** Each relation records who asserted it, what moves, which way, with what sign, as of when, and its basis: observed, inferred or modelled. A modelled harm stays labelled as modelled until someone measures it. Both ends read the same record (it is not an acknowledgement by either), so the town sees the wall in what reaches it, and the wall's owner sees the town in what it sends.

[Your city is upstream and downstream at once](/guide/your-city-is-upstream-and-downstream-at-once?from=guide) shows the same two-way idea at city scale.

## what to ask before you fund adaptation

Whether you approve a scheme, lend to one or make a grant, five questions catch most maladaptation before it is built:

1. **Where does the water, heat or sediment go after the measure is in?** Name the next place.
2. **Who is outside the project boundary and inside the hazard's path?** Were they asked?
3. **Does it still work, and still do no harm, under a hotter scenario than the base case?**
4. **What does it emit or draw down over its life:** power, refrigerant, groundwater?
5. **Who maintains the drainage, the outfall or the planting after opening, and where does the money for that work come from over its whole life?**

On a coast, the same questions separate [a living shoreline from a seawall with plants](/guide/a-living-shoreline-is-not-a-seawall-with-plants?from=guide).

## the sign shapes who could invest

The sign changes the money as well as the action. A helpful source's value already sits inside its dependents' accounts: the flood that stopped short of the town, the treatment the water company didn't need. When that source fails, they spend money on the loss. Part of that money could instead be invested in keeping the source working.

A harmful source's cost is already being spent too, as repairs, claims, clean-up and lost days downstream. Fixing the source ends that recurring spend. The source's owner, a funder or the people downstream could each choose to put money into the fix. That is the point of reading the sign: no one is handed a new bill. The money already going out as a loss is aimed at the cause. ensurance is designed to turn that money, the loss or the donation after the next flood, into an investment in the ground that stops it. Where the law already assigns liability for a harm, that runs on its own track, case by case; this method adds no charge to anyone.

What a lender needs before any of this can be financed is a named party who has chosen to invest. That is the next post: [bankable adaptation starts with the people who gain](/guide/bankable-adaptation-starts-with-a-payer?from=guide). If you are weighing a scheme and want to compare notes on what to check, [get in touch](/contact?from=guide&topic=adaptation-gap).

## faq

### is maladaptation the same as an adaptation project that failed?

No. A failed project leaves risk roughly where it was. Maladaptation raises it, moves it onto someone else, or defers it to later, often while the project looks successful on its own terms.

### can nature-based solutions be maladaptive?

Yes. A plantation that cuts streamflow downstream or a wetland placed where it backs water onto a road can shift harm like any structure. The sign test applies to every measure, living or built.

## sources

[McKinsey Global Institute — Advancing adaptation: Breaking barriers to a trillion-dollar opportunity, November 2026](https://www.mckinsey.com/mgi/our-research/Advancing-adaptation-Breaking-barriers-to-a-trillion-dollar-opportunity) — cost of the 20 measures today and at 2°C, the heat and air-conditioning shares, and the maladaptation warnings

[IPCC AR6 Working Group II, Annex II: Glossary](https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/wg2/chapter/annex-ii/) — definition of maladaptive actions

[Piggott-McKellar, Nunn, McNamara and Sekinini — Dam(n) seawalls: a case of climate change maladaptation in Fiji, 2020](https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-40552-6_4) — the two Vanua Levu seawall projects

[Standard Chartered and KPMG — Guide for Adaptation and Resilience Finance 2.0, November 2026](https://www.sc.com/en/uploads/sites/66/content/docs/Adaptation-Finance-Reports.pdf) — the Fiji example (Karoko and Korotasere, including vulnerability shifted along the coast) and the maladaptation and significant-harm screen

## the series

- [the adaptation gap is an investor gap](/guide/the-adaptation-gap-is-a-payer-gap?from=guide)
- [eight reasons adaptation doesn't get built](/guide/eight-reasons-adaptation-does-not-get-built?from=guide)
- [natural flood management: the field is the infrastructure](/guide/natural-flood-management-the-field-is-the-infrastructure?from=guide)
- [value capture for the ground that protects you](/guide/value-capture-for-the-ground-that-protects-you?from=guide)
- [maladaptation moves the harm downstream](/guide/maladaptation-moves-the-harm-downstream?from=guide)
- [bankable adaptation starts with the people who gain](/guide/bankable-adaptation-starts-with-a-payer?from=guide)
