---
title: "importance, tractability, neglectedness: scoring a living place"
canonical_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/importance-tractability-neglectedness-for-a-living-place
markdown_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/importance-tractability-neglectedness-for-a-living-place.md
subtitle: the cause is crowded. the mechanism is not. an honest ITN score has to keep those apart
category: philosophy
---

# importance, tractability, neglectedness: scoring a living place

*the cause is crowded. the mechanism is not. an honest ITN score has to keep those apart*

**Importance, tractability, neglectedness** (ITN) is effective altruism's test for where the next dollar or hour does the most good. Importance asks how much good solving a problem would do. Tractability asks what share of it more resources would solve. Neglectedness asks how much already goes to it. All three are scored on one problem, defined once.

Run on conservation as a cause, the score is poor, and effective altruists are right to say so. Run on a narrower object, it comes out differently.

A river, a wetland, a headwater forest and the soil under a harvest keep working whether or not anyone scores them. The test can still be run on the money that reaches one of them at a named place. **ensurance** is how that money gets an account, a public record and a route to the place. It is not the place.

:::johnson
**neglectedness is a property of the margin, not of the cause.** Conservation is crowded. The mechanism that lets the people who depend on a place put money into an account held for it is not. An honest score keeps the two apart.

[six tests for picking a place →](/guide/pick-a-natural-asset-like-a-givewell-charity?from=guide)
:::

![photo by Matthew Lancaster (@matthewelancaster) on unsplash](https://images.unsplash.com/photo-1601594926452-a202482e0df4?ixid=M3w4NjQwMjZ8MHwxfGNvbGxlY3Rpb258ODd8dno4VkxjblJLanN8fHx8fDJ8fDE3OTUxNDIxNTd8&ixlib=rb-4.1.0&w=1200&fit=crop&auto=format)

## the test, in 80,000 Hours' terms

80,000 Hours wrote a widely used version of the framework and calls the factors scale, solvability and neglectedness. Each has a plain definition. Scale: if the problem were solved, how good would that be? Solvability, which most people call tractability: if the resources going to the problem doubled, what fraction of it would be solved? Neglectedness: how many people and dollars already work on it?

The three multiply into good done per extra dollar, so each is scored on a logarithmic scale and the scores are added. On the neglectedness scale, a problem with $100,000 a year or less of direct spending scores 12. One with $10 billion scores 2. One with $100 billion scores 0.

The reason is diminishing returns: the best opportunities get taken first, so a crowded problem can be enormous and still a poor place for the next dollar.

The instruction that matters most is easy to skim past. The framework says to assess scale and neglectedness as a pair, on the same problem, because a different definition in each throws off the result. A common error is to take importance from a large problem and neglectedness from a small one, then multiply.

The habit worth keeping, on anything you score: write the problem in one sentence, score all three factors against that sentence, and name the factor you are least sure of.

## how effective altruists score nature, read fairly

On climate, 80,000 Hours still recommends work on the problem but calls it "far less neglected" than its highest priorities, with spending likely over $640 billion a year.

On biodiversity, Giving Green began research in February 2026. It puts philanthropy at about 2% of biodiversity funding, about $3 billion a year, beside roughly $77 billion from governments and $27 billion in private investment, against a funding gap of about $700 billion a year. Together that is over $100 billion a year, which the 80,000 Hours scale scores at 0 of 12.

Giving Green recommends two groups, The Good Food Institute and Wetlands International, and ran no quantitative cost-effectiveness analysis because biodiversity has no single outcome measure. It also says location-specific forest projects lack systemic reach. That fair objection is aimed at place-by-place work, and we come back to it under tractability.

The EA Survey 2024 (about 1,850 respondents) found climate at an all-time low as a priority, with AI risk and global health tied at the top.

Part of the community also holds that more habitat is not clearly good for the wild animals living in it. [The moral circle has no bank account](/guide/the-moral-circle-has-no-bank-account?from=guide) states that objection in its strongest form and leaves it open.

On the cause, these readings are right. Conservation as a whole is not neglected, and nothing here argues that it is.

## neglectedness is a property of the margin

The framework's own rule, one problem on all three factors, is what lets you go further. Here is a narrower problem. A named place has no account addressed to it, no written mandate for that account and no public books. So the people who depend on it, a city downstream, a farm, a utility, an insurer, have few direct ways to put money into it, even when doing so might cost them less than the loss. Most conservation money moves through governments, organisations and projects. Little of it moves into an account held for the place itself, funded by its dependents, with every payment visible to anyone.

| | conservation as a cause | an account for a place, funded by the people who depend on it |
|---|---|---|
| importance | Very large. Food, water and the economy built on them depend on living systems | Borrowed from the place it serves. The account matters because the river does. This score does not price the river |
| tractability | Mixed and hard to measure. No single outcome unit, and Giving Green ran no quantitative cost-effectiveness analysis for biodiversity | Split. The account and public record are built and live, and mandates are written account by account. Payments from the people who depend on a place are the unproven part |
| neglectedness | Low. Over $100 billion a year by Giving Green's figures; climate spending likely over $640 billion | High at this stage. Early money into the mechanism is close to the first money, so it is additional almost by construction |

Neither column carries a score. We do not have an honest one for the right-hand column, and inventing one would fail the test it claims to pass.

High neglectedness says the next dollar is additional. It does not say the dollar does good.

## tractability, said plainly

What is built: any place, purpose or group of people can have an account. Each can carry a written mandate and named keepers, receive money from anyone, and pay out on a funded release schedule with a term from three months to 512 years. Every payment in and out is on a public ledger.

What is unproven: the step that would let an account pay for itself, which is the people who depend on a place putting money into it on purpose, again and again. Condition evidence on our accounts is reported by stewards and is not verified by a third party.

Giving Green's systemic-reach objection lands here too. The design answer is that the account is the same at every place and size, so what works at one can be issued to the next without building a new institution. That is a design; reach at scale is not shown.

**ensurance** is pre-seed. Live numbers are at [/api/protocol/stats](/api/protocol/stats?from=guide): on 2026-11-20, 2,095 accounts, 26 certificates, 196 coins and 12 funded release schedules.

## a worked example: the arno

[arno-river.basin](/arno-river.basin?from=guide) is the account for the Arno, the river that runs through Florence. Its certificate, number 23, sends its mint price to the river's account. By 2026-11-20, 5,000 had been minted. Anyone can open the account and see each payment into it and when it arrived.

Scored on one problem, an account for the Arno funded by the people who depend on it: importance belongs to the river. The account adds none of its own.

Neglectedness is high at the margin the test cares about. Money for a river's care mostly runs through public agencies and projects. It does not go into an account held for the river that anyone can fund and anyone can audit. That account is young, so money put into it now is early money.

Tractability is open. The step not yet shown is the businesses and households that depend on the Arno investing in its account because it is worth it to them. Until that happens, a stranger can verify every payment that arrived and cannot yet verify that the river is better for it.

The score favours the mechanism on neglectedness and leaves tractability unproven.

## read next

[Would it have happened anyway?](/guide/would-it-have-happened-anyway?from=guide) runs the counterfactual test a high neglectedness score sets up. [Pick a natural asset the way you'd pick a GiveWell charity](/guide/pick-a-natural-asset-like-a-givewell-charity?from=guide) gives six tests for choosing the place. To run this score on a live account yourself, open [the Arno's record](/arno-river.basin?from=guide).

## frequently asked questions

### what is the importance, tractability, neglectedness framework?

It is effective altruism's test for comparing problems: how much good solving one would do, what share of it more resources would solve, and how much already goes to it. 80,000 Hours scores each factor on a log scale and adds the scores, always on the same problem.

### is conservation a neglected cause?

Not as a whole: by Giving Green's 2026 figures, more than $100 billion a year goes to biodiversity, most of it from governments. A narrower mechanism inside the cause can still be neglected, which is why the problem has to be defined before it is scored.

### how do effective altruists rate climate and biodiversity?

Mostly below their top priorities. 80,000 Hours calls climate far less neglected than its highest-priority areas, the EA Survey 2024 found climate at an all-time low, and Giving Green recommends two biodiversity groups while noting the field has no single outcome measure.

## sources

[80,000 Hours, "A framework for comparing global problems in terms of expected impact"](https://80000hours.org/articles/problem-framework/) by Robert Wiblin, last updated December 2025, read 2026-11-20. Definitions of scale, solvability and neglectedness; the logarithmic neglectedness table; the rule to assess scale and neglectedness on the same problem.

[80,000 Hours, climate change problem profile](https://80000hours.org/problem-profiles/climate-change/), read 2026-11-20. "Far less neglected"; spending likely over $640 billion a year.

[Giving Green, new biodiversity research and top biodiversity nonprofits](https://www.givinggreen.earth/post/giving-green-launches-new-biodiversity-research-and-top-biodiversity-nonprofits), 2026-02-24, and [Giving Green, biodiversity](https://www.givinggreen.earth/biodiversity), read 2026-11-20. Funding split, the gap, the two recommendations, no cost-effectiveness analysis, systemic reach.

[Rethink Priorities, EA Survey 2024, on the EA Forum](https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/CKwDgZGLipchAoxtN), read 2026-11-20. Cause priorities; climate at an all-time low.

[ensurance protocol stats](https://ensurance.app/api/protocol/stats) and [specific ensurance tokens](https://ensurance.app/api/specific/tokens), read 2026-11-20. Accounts, certificates, coins, funded release schedules, certificate #23.

## the series

1. [the test most impact investing fails](/guide/the-test-most-impact-investing-fails?from=guide)
2. [importance, tractability, neglectedness: scoring a living place](/guide/importance-tractability-neglectedness-for-a-living-place?from=guide)
3. [would it have happened anyway?](/guide/would-it-have-happened-anyway?from=guide)
4. [give now, give later, or fund something that keeps receiving](/guide/give-now-or-give-later?from=guide)
5. [effective altruists invented the impact certificate](/guide/effective-altruists-invented-the-impact-certificate?from=guide)
6. [the moral circle has no bank account](/guide/the-moral-circle-has-no-bank-account?from=guide)
7. [the risk factor nobody funds](/guide/the-risk-factor-nobody-funds?from=guide)
8. [a gift, a position or an investment](/guide/a-gift-a-position-or-an-investment?from=guide)

The giving side of the same question: [the gift isn't finished when the deduction posts](/guide/the-gift-isnt-finished-when-the-deduction-posts?from=guide).
