---
title: bankable adaptation starts with the people who gain
canonical_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/bankable-adaptation-starts-with-a-payer
markdown_url: https://ensurance.app/guide/bankable-adaptation-starts-with-a-payer.md
subtitle: "a lender can't lend against an avoided loss. it can lend alongside the people who carry that loss today and commit to invest in preventing it"
category: nature-finance
---

# bankable adaptation starts with the people who gain

*a lender can't lend against an avoided loss. it can lend alongside the people who carry that loss today and commit to invest in preventing it*

A **bankable adaptation project** is one a lender can finance because named parties have committed money to it, on a schedule, from budgets they control. Most adaptation pays off as avoided loss: money that is never spent, by people who never signed anything. That benefit is real. Bankability starts when the people who gain choose to invest in it and write that choice into a contract.

Picture a floodplain above a railway. When the river rises, the meadow takes the water and the line downstream stays open. The rail operator gains every wet winter, and already spends when the meadow can't keep up: repairs, replacement buses, lost days. None of that has ever reached the meadow, and no lender will advance money against a flood that didn't happen.

:::johnson
**a lender doesn't need the benefit to be large. it needs someone named who has chosen to invest, and put it in writing.**

A big avoided loss that nobody has put money into is a report. A modest one with named investors under contract can be a loan.

[talk through a named place →](/contact?from=guide&topic=adaptation-gap)
:::

## why avoided loss is not cash flow

McKinsey Global Institute's *Advancing adaptation* (November 2026) puts the case for adaptation plainly. Across the 20 proven measures it models, each dollar spent avoids about three dollars of damage today, and about seven at 2°C of warming, which MGI uses as a planning scenario, not a forecast. On cost-benefit alone, the work would already be built.

It isn't, and MGI names why. On the financing side, the barrier it calls **revenue risk** is the one that matters here: a sea dike or a detention basin protects many people and usually earns nothing. In higher-income regions, where the implementer is usually creditworthy, MGI finds that misaligned incentives (the party that funds the work is not the one that gains) and revenue risk are the most common barriers.

Avoided loss shows up in someone else's accounts as a cost that didn't happen. The insurer pays fewer claims, the water company treats less silt, the railway runs on time. None of those savings usually reach the project unless the people who keep them choose to send part of them there, by contract.

> **The benefit of adaptation lands on the dependents. The debt lands on the project. Bankability is the commitment that connects them.**

## five ways to turn a benefit into revenue

MGI lists five ways to translate resilience benefits into a predictable revenue stream. They are MGI's taxonomy. The "adds a charge?" column is our reading, not MGI's: some routes add a charge to someone, others redirect money people already spend.

| mechanism | where the money comes from | adds a charge? | MGI's example |
|---|---|---|---|
| **User fees** | Everyone who uses a service, through a fee | Yes | Copenhagen's cloudburst plan, funded through water-utility bills; Miami Beach's stormwater fee |
| **Beneficiary payments** | The parties who gain, in proportion to the gain | Yes, as Sacramento does it (an assessment) | Sacramento assessment districts, priced to each zone's reduced flood risk |
| **Value capture** | Developers given building rights on city land | Yes, a contribution tied to the right to build | Boston's building rights tied to coastal protection (too new to judge) |
| **Payments tied to future savings** | Money a household or firm would otherwise spend later, redirected from the saving | No | MyStrongHome roofs, repaid from insurance-premium savings |
| **Asset bundling** | Users of a second, revenue-earning function on the same asset | Yes, for a second service | Kuala Lumpur's SMART tunnel |

The SMART tunnel is the cleanest picture of the last row. It is a 9.7 km stormwater bypass with a 3 km double-deck toll motorway built inside it, opened in 2007 under a build-operate-transfer concession. On most days drivers use the road for a toll. When forecast flows reach about 150 cubic metres per second, operators clear and close the motorway, and in a long storm the road decks carry floodwater. The toll is a revenue line that helped secure private financing for a flood channel that would have earned nothing on its own.

All five give a gain an address. Fees, assessments and value-capture charges do it by adding a cost; cities use them, and ensurance doesn't build those. Our design works from two ideas: savings that would otherwise be lost to damage, and beneficiaries who choose to invest instead of being assessed. [Value capture for the ground that protects you](/guide/value-capture-for-the-ground-that-protects-you?from=guide) takes the value-capture and savings rows further.

## the bankability buckets are small, and mostly not nature

MGI sizes protection at developed-economy standards at about **$1.2 trillion a year by 2050** at 2°C. It sorts that need into five responses. Two are about who gains and who funds:

:::stat
~$70B/yr | realign incentives (levees, irrigation in higher-income rural areas)
~$40B/yr | enable bankability (about 5% of the total)
38% | share of the $1.2T that is active cooling alone | warning
:::

The $1.2 trillion is not a nature market. MGI's 20 measures are mostly engineered: air-conditioning alone is 38% of the total and irrigation 16%. Nature-based lines (urban trees, fuel management, swales, mangroves) add up to about a tenth. Neither bucket above is a nature bucket.

What carries over is the shape. Where the borrower can borrow and the work clearly pays society, the thing missing is a committed investor under contract. That is the gap a floodplain, a wetland or a forested headwater sits in. The living system does the work, and the people who gain already spend money when it fails. Nobody has given them a way to invest in it.

## the lender's test: monetisation, attribution, materiality

Standard Chartered and KPMG's *Guide for Adaptation and Resilience Finance* (GARF 2.0, November 2026) sets out the test lenders are asked to meet. Avoided loss is not profit unless it is monetised. An activity counts as driving profitability only with a credible **monetisation pathway** that reaches the investor, a measurable financial effect, **attribution** to the intervention against a defined baseline, **materiality** to the asset or borrower, and a positive risk-adjusted return. The pathways it accepts include cost savings, contractual payments, and investor-yield instruments such as parametric insurance. For nature, it names reduced insurance premiums and availability or performance payments among the revenue routes.

So a project is bankable when it can answer three questions in writing. Who has committed money, and under what contract? How much of the benefit comes from this work rather than the weather? Is the effect material to the borrower or asset being financed? A meadow above a railway answers them once the railway invests part of what it now loses to floods, the meadow's effect is measured against a baseline, and the commitment is material to the project.

## what a closed deal shows

MGI's own proof case is a closed deal in Lancashire, and it isn't ours. After Storm Desmond in 2015, the Wyre catchment natural flood management project lined up five beneficiaries: Flood Re, United Utilities, the Environment Agency, Wyre Council and the North West Regional Flood and Coastal Committee. Together they contracted about £2 million in payments. Those payments are the repayment source for a nine-year £850,000 loan arranged by Triodos Bank UK, alongside a grant of about £627,000, for ponds, hedgerows and woodland upstream. MGI reports a modelled 5–15% reduction in flood impact.

Two details matter for anyone pricing the next one. Outcome-based payments start in year six, once monitoring by Wyre Rivers Trust confirms the work was delivered. Bankability came from five named beneficiaries committing, in our reading putting into the land money they would otherwise lose to floods. Even then the payments alone would not have carried it: a grant covered part of the up-front cost. [Natural flood management: the field is the infrastructure](/guide/natural-flood-management-the-field-is-the-infrastructure?from=guide) tells the case in full.

## outcome-linked payment: how parametric ensurance works

Wyre ties later payments to a monitored result. A parametric rule does the same job with less discretion. One agreed reading, from one agreed source, on one agreed schedule, decides whether money moves.

[Parametric ensurance](/guide/what-parametric-ensurance-actually-does?from=guide) points that rule at the living system. Money set aside for a named place is released when a reading shows the place held a baseline, or that its condition improved: the wetland stayed wet through the dry month, the floodplain stayed connected. Parametric insurance pays when an index trips, usually after the damage has started. Parametric ensurance funds the place while it is still working.

That is how it is designed, not a track record. No reading has moved money yet. For a lender, the point is structural: a commitment that follows a stated reading is easier to underwrite than one that follows a committee's mood.

## what a lender would see on a named parcel

[*Ensurance*](/natural-assets?from=guide) starts from the natural asset and works out to the people who depend on it. For a named parcel, the record a credit reader would look at is built from the same parts the redirecting routes above share:

1. **The source.** The parcel itself: the floodplain, the wetland, the headwater forest, with its condition and what it does each year. The land is the infrastructure, not a co-benefit of something grey.
2. **The people who depend on it.** The named parties whose loss it reduces: the insurer, the water company, the rail operator, the town.
3. **What they already spend.** Claims, treatment, repairs, downtime, and grants or donations after the fact. This is the money that can be redirected; the design asks for no new cost.
4. **What they've chosen to invest.** Each commits on its own terms and budget cycle, not all on one date.
5. **The routed proceeds.** Investments land in the natural asset's own account and route on to the work and the people who keep it, with their agreement, on a [public record](/proceeds?from=guide) rather than an annual report.
6. **The reading.** Where a release depends on condition, the observation it reads is the one anyone can see.

Be clear about the stage. This is the design. No ensurance contract of the Wyre kind has been signed yet, and tracing every dependent of a parcel in both directions is still in build. What the design changes is the first question: not "how big is the benefit?" but "who, by name, has chosen to invest in it?"

## what this does not fix

Named investors answer revenue risk. They do not answer every barrier. MGI finds counterparty risk sits under about three-quarters of adaptation costs in Sub-Saharan Africa, India and Emerging Asia, where the borrower itself is hard to lend to. There, it is the first barrier, ahead of the revenue question. Concessional loans, guarantees and first-loss capital from public and philanthropic funds do that work, and MGI's blended-finance examples come from that world. [Where you sit in a blended finance stack](/guide/where-you-sit-in-a-blended-finance-stack?from=guide) maps those seats.

Named investors also don't make a bond into a floodplain. A [resilience bond is still a bond](/guide/a-resilience-bond-is-still-a-bond?from=guide), and a [resilience finance pipeline](/guide/resilience-finance-is-still-a-pipeline?from=guide) still needs the living system it sits on to keep working. The people who gain, investing what they would otherwise lose, let money reach that system.

## frequently asked questions

### what makes an adaptation project bankable?

A bankable adaptation project has named parties contracted to commit money on a schedule, a measurable financial effect attributed to the work against a baseline, and an effect material to what is being financed. Avoided loss alone is not cash flow.

### why don't adaptation projects get financed if they pay off?

Because the benefit lands on people who have no way to invest in the project. MGI estimates adaptation returns about three dollars per dollar today, but in higher-income regions misaligned incentives and revenue risk are the main barriers.

### how can a nature-based project create revenue without raising anyone's costs?

MGI lists five routes: user fees, beneficiary payments, value capture, payments tied to future savings, and asset bundling. Fees and assessments add a charge. Payments tied to savings, and beneficiaries who choose to invest, redirect money already being lost. The Wyre catchment project in England combined five beneficiaries' contracted payments to repay a nine-year loan.

### is the $1.2 trillion adaptation need a nature market?

No. About 38% of MGI's $1.2 trillion is air-conditioning and about a tenth is nature-based. The useful lesson for nature is the missing investor, not the headline size.

## next steps

If you finance, insure or depend on a place that holds back flood, drought or heat, start with the people who gain, not the benefit estimate: who they are, what they already spend when the place fails, and on what cycle they could invest. If you want to work through that for a specific floodplain, wetland or catchment, [get in touch](/contact?from=guide&topic=adaptation-gap).

Nothing here is investment, legal, or credit advice.

## sources

[McKinsey Global Institute — Advancing adaptation: Breaking barriers to a trillion-dollar opportunity, November 2026](https://www.mckinsey.com/mgi/our-research/Advancing-adaptation-Breaking-barriers-to-a-trillion-dollar-opportunity) — benefit-to-cost ratios, $1.2T at 2°C, response buckets, revenue mechanisms, Wyre case, regional barriers

[Standard Chartered and KPMG — Guide for Adaptation and Resilience Finance 2.0, November 2026](https://www.sc.com/en/uploads/sites/66/content/docs/Adaptation-Finance-Reports.pdf) — monetisation, attribution and materiality tests; accepted revenue routes

[Green Finance Institute — Wyre River natural flood management project](https://hive.greenfinanceinstitute.com/gfihive/toolkit/initial-project-scoping/wyre-river-natural-flood-management-project) — buyers, loan, grant, outcome payments from year six

[The Rivers Trust — Investing in nature: Wyre catchment NFM](https://www.theriverstrust.org/news/investing-in-nature-wyre-catchment-nfm) — project background

[Malay Mail — How KL's SMART tunnel switches from highway to flood channel, 29 October 2026](https://malaymail.com/news/malaysia/2026/10/29/a-road-when-its-dry-a-river-when-it-pours-how-kls-smart-tunnel-switches-from-highway-to-flood-channel/240340) — length, concession, operating modes

## the series

- [the adaptation gap is an investor gap](/guide/the-adaptation-gap-is-a-payer-gap?from=guide)
- [eight reasons adaptation doesn't get built](/guide/eight-reasons-adaptation-does-not-get-built?from=guide)
- [natural flood management: the field is the infrastructure](/guide/natural-flood-management-the-field-is-the-infrastructure?from=guide)
- [value capture for the ground that protects you](/guide/value-capture-for-the-ground-that-protects-you?from=guide)
- [maladaptation moves the harm downstream](/guide/maladaptation-moves-the-harm-downstream?from=guide)
- [bankable adaptation starts with the people who gain](/guide/bankable-adaptation-starts-with-a-payer?from=guide)
